This is a follow up to this VR describing a few of my more divisive / strange opinions alongside really just any elements of this VR that I felt are worth talking about. I disagree with a lot of elements of the official VR, and want a more public decryption as to why instead of just arguing on Discord.
Standard VR
Wonder Guard at number one: I think this may have been controversial in some earlier days of the meta, but as this format has developed I feel it's become increasingly obvious than Wonder Guard is easily better than any individual Pokemon. While it is true that every WGer (other than Audino) has major issues that hinder them individually, together they are easily better than Chansey even. The fact that teams without at least 2 Wonder Guard mons are still often defined by it more than any other aspect speaks volumes about how powerful it really is. I genuinely struggle to speak on why I made this decision since it frankly just feels obvious. Even with the ability being far worse than in gen 6 it's still Wonder Guard.
>
: As time has gone on, people have just thought more and more of Zygarde, which is entirely fair. At this point the "standard" opinion seems to have shifted into Zygarde being the 2nd best overall Pokemon behind Chansey. I disagree with this though. A large part of Zygarde getting a lot more appreciation is that Prankster itself got a lot more appreciation, and while Zyg is definitely the best overall Prankster user other Prankster users have also gotten a lot more appreciation and give Zygarde a lot of competition. Alongside this since Zygarde is the general best Prankster a lot of the meta is devoted to specifically beating Zygarde. Things like putting Ice Shard on a sweeper or Shadow Tag users that beat it are very prevalent and make using Zygarde kinda annoying since everyone is hyper-prepared for it. Contrasting that, Mewtwo-X is just about exactly as good as it's always been. While some checks like Slowbro have become more prevelant it still threatens pretty much every Pokemon with proper coverage. I believe that while MMX and Zygarde are very close, MMX is
Slightly better.
in 10th: This is probably my biggest divulging opinion among high tier Pokemon. I believe that Slowbro is way better than A-. With it's fantastic Slow Pivoting, amazing Physical Bulk and very good typing, Slowbro is just about the best Physical Photon check there is and similarly good against Sunsteel attackers. While people tend to gravitate to the Wonder Guard set for Slowbro, I believe it's just as good in non-WG sets as well. I've used it very effectively as Prankster, the Fur Coat set is fantastic notably walling almost every MMX set other than the occasional Moongeist and it's an effective Bounce mon too. I genuinely believe it to be better than Mega Steelix since a lot of Steelix's role has been taken over by Doublade.
in A-: Deo-A is a good mon don't get me wrong, but I really don't feel that it's on the same level as the A tier mons. The only teamstyle where Deo-A truly excells is PsySurge, outside of PsySurge it's a good Magic Guard mon but really not much else. The Magic Guard set itself is flawed too, mostly only fitting on HO or some Offense teams unlike all of the mons in A which are a lot more versitile. As menioned it's great on PsySurge, the powered up Photon and Priority immunity makes Deo-A one of the absolute best mons on PsySurge teams easily. The excellent Speed tier and great mixed attacking power is all still very good outside of Psysurge but I don't think it's good enough for an A placement. It's not on the level of Pokemon like Necrozma DM, Kartana or Slaking
in A-: I don't have much to say on Aggron partially since I haven't seen it much and partially just 'cause it's kinda boring. It could and maybe should be a bit higher, but I lack the experience to say. Compared to Steelix is has a
generally better defensive typing and a higher attack stat, but it's a bit less bulky and doesn't have STAB on Thousand Waves. If you're not using TWaves you'd probably prefer Aggron. It's a perfectly good mon, probably good enough for A in retrospect. Boring but effective.
in B: Not actually a controversial placement, but I'm just bringing it up 'cause I've realized since making this VR that POgre sucks and belongs in B-. I have never seen it actually do anything worthwhile when I've fought it.
in B-: Dawn Wings could probably be higher than this, I have never seen it used outside of WG so I'm mostly spitballing with this placement. Being able to defensively check a lot of Photon attackers combined with solid general bulk giving it setup opportunities is still very good on a non-WG set and it's still strong with Lunalium-Z. Probably good enough for at least B in retrospect, I've given this mon more thought since I made this VR.
in B- and
in C: Meh, they're ok. Such a strong Shadow Sneak is good, but Banette has the issue of being forced into Band (though non-Band sets could be interesting, Marowak prob does that better) and Marowak has the issue of being too weak and Rocks vulnerable. They also just both have a lot of competition as priority attackers, unlike -Ate mons they don't get Fake Out (you can maybe use it on Marowak but it's a big sacrifice) so they can't chip down mons with it or break Sashes. I think Marowak is worse since it doesn't kill anything.
Please UR this thing it does nothing. Only "worth" it on ladder where annoying people run stuff like 3 OHKO moves Deo-S, and I don't think we should rank mons based on the lowest denomenator of players.
if this thing ever gets ranked I'm writing an essay on why it's terrible and never worth it and dumb.
Wonder Guard VR
being so much higher than
: Melo is just kinda better like 90% of the time, Guru is less bulky and has less SpAtk in return for slow pivoting, but it's still not even that good at slow pivoting. Notably being faster than the crowded 50 Speed tier. Melo is better but for how relatively low the cost of using Guru is, it can be better on some offense teams which don't mind the drop in bulk as much.
in A-: I might be overrating this thing off of personal experience, I've had teams with bad matchups against this thing and it can be very scary sometimes. It's bulk is mediocre but it's typing is solid and it has good attack. It's fine I guess.
in B+: I feel like opinions on Gigas are either to just rank it alongside Slaking or slap it into C tier, but I'm just really unique and different so I didn't do that. I think Slak is a very good WGer and the cost of using Gigas over Slak is very small and very occasionally worth it. Less potential for Wishpassing, dying to Innards a little easier and lower physical bulk in exchange for slightly higher special bulk. If you're having a bit of trouble with Special Photon specifically than you could maybe justify it? Idk this probably belongs in C, it's completely pointless to ever use over Slak.
in B: Tbh I just didn't know where to rank it. compared to Necrozma DW the extra bulk is probably worth it occasionally on some bulkier teams but the drop in power isn't ideal. I have very little to say, it's probably usable.
in B-: Similar to POgre on the standard VR, this placement isn't really weird I'm just mentioning it to say that in retrospect it belongs in C, this thing sucks.
in B-: The cooler POgre, bordering on B for me. Dying to Photon really sucks but it also isn't weak to any of the most common coverage attacks Sunsteel attackers use (other than Kartana's Grass moves), has respectable bulk and STAB on TWaves. Seems fairly underrated in my admittedly limited use of it.
in C: In retrospect this should probably be UR. Having a Steel type WGer with actually good bulk that isn't weak to Fighting is cool, but needing to hold Eviolite combined with the weaknesses Ghost brings is just not good enough for me to call it justified.