Terrastalizing has been a bit underwhelming to me. Its not the automatic KO machine it was being hyped up as going in, and honestly reading the entire thread I feel like theres a solid group of people who want it gone because its different and creates a new metagame. Its normal for most games to have radical gameplay shifts if not entire genre shifts but for some reason pokemon needs to be the same for 20 years and forever. Most likely gen10 gamefreak dumps terra themselves and makes a new mechanic entirely, so why not just play something different for a change?
Strong agreement, but It seems like this isnt a popular idea on smogon. Ive never understand why more metagames dont fork out into multiple paths. A terra ladder and a non terra ladder for OU seems very obvious as a solution. Let the player base decide which one they want to play and enjoy more in the long run. I find it quite sad that a fun and fascinating mechanic is going to be thrown in the garbage with a quickban before most people can even play with it.
Edit: Should mention I appreciate finch's take that the most blatant offenders get banned and then see if its still generally a problem. Flutter Mane would be OP in any metagame for instance. I feel like Terra when used by 'normal' pokes that are not obviously broken is both manageable and very fun.
I have no ball in the game, but curious about the response.
Since Tera and non-Tera metagames would shape up very differently and especially considering bans, maybe running both simultaneously could be an option? It'd be a shame to miss out on how either would develop with or without Tera, both look quite interesting to me.
Of course it'd be extra work and a hassle working out how that would impact other tiers and how that should be handled.
I've had the same thoughts on say a XY/ORAS split when the latter released, for the same reasons.
Strong agreement, but It seems like this isnt a popular idea on smogon. Ive never understand why more metagames dont fork out into multiple paths. A terra ladder and a non terra ladder for OU seems very obvious as a solution. Let the player base decide which one they want to play and enjoy more in the long run. I find it quite sad that a fun and fascinating mechanic is going to be thrown in the garbage with a quickban before most people can even play with it.
Edit: Should mention I appreciate finch's take that the most blatant offenders get banned and then see if its still generally a problem. Flutter Mane would be OP in any metagame for instance. I feel like Terra when used by 'normal' pokes that are not obviously broken is both manageable and very fun.