What happens when an army is sent into an already controlled supply center (eg not neutral)
Is this specific to armies or are fleets also affected?
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2024 Smog Awards!
Board Game Diplomacy at the Roulette Wheel - GAME OVER [2-way Germany + France draw]
- Thread starter Dead by Daylight
- Start date
Is this specific to armies or are fleets also affected?
How long does this last for, please?
This lasts one year (takes effect in Winter / Summer if there is one).
Neutral supply centers are the only affected ones - already occupied ones are free to take, this is also non-specific to armies (fleets also get affected)
Thank you so much DBD for the responses! I know it seems nitpicky but some of these things affect small decisions, and if not decisions then the way we view the game
One thing I would also like to know is that you have been crossing out the modifiers already selected
-when modifiers are crossed out I assume this to mean they will not be selected again — what happens when all modifiers are crossed out?
-also, what happens when modifiers are chosen via double or nothing — can crossed out modifiers be chosen — are modifiers chosen crossed out?
One thing I would also like to know is that you have been crossing out the modifiers already selected
-when modifiers are crossed out I assume this to mean they will not be selected again — what happens when all modifiers are crossed out?
-also, what happens when modifiers are chosen via double or nothing — can crossed out modifiers be chosen — are modifiers chosen crossed out?
Crossed out modifiers are not rolled again until all are crossed out - once that happens, they all reset to be available again. This goes for DoN rolls too.
DoN rolls are just normal rolls, so the mods picked will be crossed out.
Fall 1902 [Retreats]
An exciting cycle! Turkey turns on Russia with Austria's help, as Italy looks to gain naval ground in the Balkans. England continues to be encroached on, with an invalid order only further compounding their troubles as there is now a French force in London! A couple of SC changes here: Russia takes Norway, France takes Portugal, and Turkey takes Rumania. The Tsars face a defeat, however - they are kicked out of Galicia by Austrian forces and now have to retreat.
Russia (sunny004 and LonelyNess), please submit your retreat order to me as soon as possible before tomorrow at 7 PM GMT-5.
Once the retreat comes in, winter will arrive.
Austria
A Boh S Vie - Gal SUCCEEDS
A Bud S Bul - Rum SUCCEEDS
F Gre S Smy - AEG FAILS (Invalid Order)
A Ser S Bul - Rum SUCCEEDS
A Vie - Gal SUCCEEDS
England
F Cly - Lvp SUCCEEDS
F Edi - Lon FAILS (Invalid move path)
A Lon - Wal SUCCEEDS
France
A Bel - Lon SUCCEEDS
A Bur H SUCCEEDS
F ENG S Bel - Lon SUCCEEDS
F LYO - WES SUCCEEDS
A Spa - Por SUCCEEDS
Germany
F HEL - Den SUCCEEDS
A Hol H SUCCEEDS
A Kie S Mun SUCCEEDS
A Mun H SUCCEEDS
F NTH C Bel - Lon SUCCEEDS
Italy
F ION - EAS FAILS (Attack strength is not greater than the prevent strength)
F Nap - ION FAILS (Attack strength is not greater than the defend strength)
A Tun H SUCCEEDS
A Ven H SUCCEEDS
Russia
F BLA S Gal - Rum FAILS (Disrupted)
A Gal - Rum FAILS (Attack strength is not greater than the prevent strength)Select a retreat optionDISBANDSilWar
A Stp - Nwy SUCCEEDS
F Swe S Stp - Nwy SUCCEEDS
A Ukr S Gal - Rum SUCCEEDS
Turkey
A Ank - Arm SUCCEEDS
A Bul - Rum SUCCEEDS
F Con - BLA FAILS (Attack strength is not greater than the defend strength)
F Smy - EAS FAILS (Attack strength is not greater than the prevent strength)
A Boh S Vie - Gal SUCCEEDS
A Bud S Bul - Rum SUCCEEDS
F Gre S Smy - AEG FAILS (Invalid Order)
A Ser S Bul - Rum SUCCEEDS
A Vie - Gal SUCCEEDS
England
F Cly - Lvp SUCCEEDS
F Edi - Lon FAILS (Invalid move path)
A Lon - Wal SUCCEEDS
France
A Bel - Lon SUCCEEDS
A Bur H SUCCEEDS
F ENG S Bel - Lon SUCCEEDS
F LYO - WES SUCCEEDS
A Spa - Por SUCCEEDS
Germany
F HEL - Den SUCCEEDS
A Hol H SUCCEEDS
A Kie S Mun SUCCEEDS
A Mun H SUCCEEDS
F NTH C Bel - Lon SUCCEEDS
Italy
F ION - EAS FAILS (Attack strength is not greater than the prevent strength)
F Nap - ION FAILS (Attack strength is not greater than the defend strength)
A Tun H SUCCEEDS
A Ven H SUCCEEDS
Russia
F BLA S Gal - Rum FAILS (Disrupted)
A Gal - Rum FAILS (Attack strength is not greater than the prevent strength)Select a retreat optionDISBANDSilWar
A Stp - Nwy SUCCEEDS
F Swe S Stp - Nwy SUCCEEDS
A Ukr S Gal - Rum SUCCEEDS
Turkey
A Ank - Arm SUCCEEDS
A Bul - Rum SUCCEEDS
F Con - BLA FAILS (Attack strength is not greater than the defend strength)
F Smy - EAS FAILS (Attack strength is not greater than the prevent strength)
An exciting cycle! Turkey turns on Russia with Austria's help, as Italy looks to gain naval ground in the Balkans. England continues to be encroached on, with an invalid order only further compounding their troubles as there is now a French force in London! A couple of SC changes here: Russia takes Norway, France takes Portugal, and Turkey takes Rumania. The Tsars face a defeat, however - they are kicked out of Galicia by Austrian forces and now have to retreat.
Russia (sunny004 and LonelyNess), please submit your retreat order to me as soon as possible before tomorrow at 7 PM GMT-5.
Once the retreat comes in, winter will arrive.
Help
Winter 1902.
A Gal retreats to War.
More builds coming up - the growing theaters are going to make this season interesting as to who builds what and where.
France [+2 builds] - gained London and Portugal
Turkey [+1 build] - gained Rumania
Russia [+1 build] - gained Norway
Italy [no changes]
Germany [no changes]
Austria [no changes]
England [+1 disband] - lost London
Get your build orders in by 7 PM GMT-5 tomorrow.
A Gal retreats to War.
More builds coming up - the growing theaters are going to make this season interesting as to who builds what and where.
France [+2 builds] - gained London and Portugal
Turkey [+1 build] - gained Rumania
Russia [+1 build] - gained Norway
Italy [no changes]
Germany [no changes]
Austria [no changes]
England [+1 disband] - lost London
Get your build orders in by 7 PM GMT-5 tomorrow.
Last edited:
Rigged
Spring 1903.
Come on people, get it together - another NMR even with the delayed resolution. It's starting to get annoying at this point. Anyways, Russia seemingly gears up for an assault on Austria and Turkey, while France continues trying to gain naval dominance. England, meanwhile, tries to hold the line, but things are looking grim.
The modifier for this year is...
How The Tables Turn: This Winter phase, any country forced to disband n units instead disbands n units from other countries.
Orders in by Sunday, December 29 at 7 PM GMT-5, please.
Russia builds A Sev
France builds F Mar and F Bre
Turkey NMRs this cycle
England disbands F LVP
France builds F Mar and F Bre
Turkey NMRs this cycle
England disbands F LVP
Come on people, get it together - another NMR even with the delayed resolution. It's starting to get annoying at this point. Anyways, Russia seemingly gears up for an assault on Austria and Turkey, while France continues trying to gain naval dominance. England, meanwhile, tries to hold the line, but things are looking grim.
The modifier for this year is...
How The Tables Turn: This Winter phase, any country forced to disband n units instead disbands n units from other countries.
Orders in by Sunday, December 29 at 7 PM GMT-5, please.
Could you have rolled that during the winter itself instead? That would've been way more convenient
Spring 1903 [Retreats].
Austria faces an ignominous retreat from their power position of Galicia as Turkey and Russia seem to have fallen into one anothers' good graces again. France arranges for some southern moves, but a potential German stab in London puts their position at risk. It's shaping up to be an exciting Fall!
Austria (StupidFlandrs48), please submit your retreats ASAP - Fall 1903 will begin when I receive the retreat orders.
Austria faces an ignominous retreat from their power position of Galicia as Turkey and Russia seem to have fallen into one anothers' good graces again. France arranges for some southern moves, but a potential German stab in London puts their position at risk. It's shaping up to be an exciting Fall!
Austria (StupidFlandrs48), please submit your retreats ASAP - Fall 1903 will begin when I receive the retreat orders.
its okay ImaginaryNeon im here to save you
Fall 1903.
It's heating up in the Balkans, as a stab from Italy on Austria seemingly puts the Empire under threat of collapse, being attacked from all sides. It makes its first concession by giving up Galicia and retreating to Vienna, potentially trying to regroup and fight back.
Orders by New Year's Day (January 1st) at 7 PM EST (GMT-5).
It's heating up in the Balkans, as a stab from Italy on Austria seemingly puts the Empire under threat of collapse, being attacked from all sides. It makes its first concession by giving up Galicia and retreating to Vienna, potentially trying to regroup and fight back.
Orders by New Year's Day (January 1st) at 7 PM EST (GMT-5).
Winter 1903.
An interesting Fall season! Germany invades Belgium as Turkey turns its back on Russia - German troops also land uncomfortably close to the Russian back line and France gears up for a tussle with Italy.
Germany [+2 builds] - gained London and Belgium
Turkey [+2 builds] - gained Sevastopol and waived a build last year
England [no changes]
Italy [no changes]
Austria [no changes]
Russia [-1 disband] - lost Sevastopol
France [-2 disbands] - lost London and Belgium
Do keep in mind that Russia and France do not have to disband their units! Instead, they can select 1 and 2 units respectively of their choice to disband on the board, irrespective of country. These units will be returned at the end of next winter (if the countries they take from are still alive, of course).
GM's Notes:
I accidentally inputted Austria's move and subsequent support of F Gre -> Bul(sc) as F Gre -> Bul(ec), this mistake has been fixed. Let me know of any other mistakes.
Get your orders in by tomorrow at 7 PM EST (GMT-5).
| A Boh - Tyr A Bud - Rum F Gre - Bul/sc A Ser S Gre - Bul/sc A Vie - Tri |
| F Edi - NTH A Yor - Lvp |
| F ENG - NTH F LYO C Spa - Tus F MAO - Naf A Mar - Pie A Spa - Tus A Wal H F WES - TYS |
| F BAL C Ber - Lvn A Ber - Lvn A Lon H A Mun - Tyr F NTH - Bel |
| F ION - Gre F Nap - ION A Tun H A Ven - Tri |
| F BLA S Bul - Rum A Gal H A Nwy - Fin F Swe - Nwy A Ukr S Gal A War S Gal |
| F AEG S Con - Bul/sc A Bul - Rum F Con - Bul/sc A Rum - Sev |
An interesting Fall season! Germany invades Belgium as Turkey turns its back on Russia - German troops also land uncomfortably close to the Russian back line and France gears up for a tussle with Italy.
Germany [+2 builds] - gained London and Belgium
Turkey [+2 builds] - gained Sevastopol and waived a build last year
England [no changes]
Italy [no changes]
Austria [no changes]
Russia [-1 disband] - lost Sevastopol
France [-2 disbands] - lost London and Belgium
Do keep in mind that Russia and France do not have to disband their units! Instead, they can select 1 and 2 units respectively of their choice to disband on the board, irrespective of country. These units will be returned at the end of next winter (if the countries they take from are still alive, of course).
GM's Notes:
I accidentally inputted Austria's move and subsequent support of F Gre -> Bul(sc) as F Gre -> Bul(ec), this mistake has been fixed. Let me know of any other mistakes.
Get your orders in by tomorrow at 7 PM EST (GMT-5).
Last edited:
Spring 1904.
A LVN, A Ven and F Nap were disbanded.
After an excruciating time on Microsoft Paint, we've got our update. France and Russia both choose some strategic disbands, but a potential stab from any major country here could be massive for the gamestate. Things are heating up, that's for sure.
This year's modifier is...
The Host's Specialty: You are randomly assigned to be either a liar or a truth-teller. You may not reveal which one you are, but you must:
Orders in by January 4th, 2025.
A LVN, A Ven and F Nap were disbanded.
After an excruciating time on Microsoft Paint, we've got our update. France and Russia both choose some strategic disbands, but a potential stab from any major country here could be massive for the gamestate. Things are heating up, that's for sure.
This year's modifier is...
The Host's Specialty: You are randomly assigned to be either a liar or a truth-teller. You may not reveal which one you are, but you must:
- Liars: submit the opposite of everything discussed
- Truth-tellers: submit exactly what was discussed
- This lasts 1 year.
- You may not hint at your alignment by any means (ex: through a symbolic move suggestion) - doing so will incur a penalty.
Orders in by January 4th, 2025.
An important addendum: if you are asked directly for your orders, you must supply what you are either planning or not planning to do.
To the Liars: "The exact opposite" of your discussions means you cannot submit any order that you said you would submit.
To the Liars: "The exact opposite" of your discussions means you cannot submit any order that you said you would submit.
An update: You are no longer required to provide orders to those who ask you directly for them.
However, if asked and ignored, you may not communicate with the asker regarding orders for either of your countries (you may theorize what other countries would order, but you may not discuss your or the asker’s orders with the asker).
However, if asked and ignored, you may not communicate with the asker regarding orders for either of your countries (you may theorize what other countries would order, but you may not discuss your or the asker’s orders with the asker).
Fall 1904.
A more legible map has arrived, rejoice. Austria takes the opportunity to seemingly stab Turkey by waltzing into Bulgaria, although Turkey can recapture it next turn - perhaps this is the wedge in what looks to be an "Eastern Triple" for now? France casually invades what's left of Italy, although an NMR doesn't help matters. Meanwhile, Germany and Russia look to scare one another, with Austria joining the fray to aid the anti-Germany push. Speaking of Russia, they get into the North Sea to both protect England as well as menace Germany from another angle. A pivotal cycle lies ahead.
F ION is disbanded. It's now Fall 1904, get your orders in by 7 PM GMT-5 on the 6th.
Russia:
F Nwy - NTH
A Fin - Swe
A Ukr - Mos
A Gal - Sil
A War S A Gal - Sil
F BLA - Sev
Italy
NMR
Germany
Lon to Yor
Belgium to NTH
Kiel to Den
Berlin to Pru
Munich to Silesia
Baltic s Berlin-Pru
France
Wal s Lon Yor
ENG s Bel NTH
Pie Ven
Tus Rom
TYS Nap
Naf Tun
LYO WES
Austria
A Vie-Tyr
A Boh S Gal-Sil
A Bud-Tri
A Ser-Bul
F Gre S AEG-ION
Turkey
a sev-arm
f aeg-ion
f smy-eas
f con-aeg
f ank-con
a rum s a bud
England
A Lvp -> Wal
F Edi S F Nwy -> NTH
F Nwy - NTH
A Fin - Swe
A Ukr - Mos
A Gal - Sil
A War S A Gal - Sil
F BLA - Sev
Italy
NMR
Germany
Lon to Yor
Belgium to NTH
Kiel to Den
Berlin to Pru
Munich to Silesia
Baltic s Berlin-Pru
France
Wal s Lon Yor
ENG s Bel NTH
Pie Ven
Tus Rom
TYS Nap
Naf Tun
LYO WES
Austria
A Vie-Tyr
A Boh S Gal-Sil
A Bud-Tri
A Ser-Bul
F Gre S AEG-ION
Turkey
a sev-arm
f aeg-ion
f smy-eas
f con-aeg
f ank-con
a rum s a bud
England
A Lvp -> Wal
F Edi S F Nwy -> NTH
A more legible map has arrived, rejoice. Austria takes the opportunity to seemingly stab Turkey by waltzing into Bulgaria, although Turkey can recapture it next turn - perhaps this is the wedge in what looks to be an "Eastern Triple" for now? France casually invades what's left of Italy, although an NMR doesn't help matters. Meanwhile, Germany and Russia look to scare one another, with Austria joining the fray to aid the anti-Germany push. Speaking of Russia, they get into the North Sea to both protect England as well as menace Germany from another angle. A pivotal cycle lies ahead.
F ION is disbanded. It's now Fall 1904, get your orders in by 7 PM GMT-5 on the 6th.
Last edited:
I can't even comprehend what's supposed to be happening.
Here's the map going into Fall 1904.
Fall 1904 [Retreats]
It looks like we're heading into some warfare on all fronts! Multiple supply centers change fronts - Turkey loses both Bulgaria and Sevastopol, putting a serious dent into their plans this winter, while the Austrian front successfully enters Munich. It's not all doom and gloom for Germany, though, as they stop the bleeding by getting into Liverpool as England desperately tries to hold their home centers. Russia, meanwhile, bears down on the Kaiser's with Austria's support, while France gains a whopping 4 centers.
Italy (CrreamyKitty) has been eliminated. Thanks for playing, CK - it was a tough game for you once France went after you and you got your defenses completely removed. Hope you had a good time at least at the start of the game.
Germany (Alice Kazumi and M2H) and England (ImaginaryNeon), please submit your retreat orders for A Mun and A Lvp promptly. Once that happens, we move into Winter of 1904.
Russia:
A Mos - Lvn
A War - Pru
A Sil S A War - Pru
A Swe H
F Nwy S A Swe
F Sev H
Austria:
A Tyr - Mun
A Boh S A Tyr - Mun
A Bul S F Gre
A Tri - Tyr
F Gre S A Bul
Germany:
A Yor - Lvp
A Mun - Tyr [fails, dislodged]
A Kie -> Swe [invalid order]
A Pru -> Ber
F BAL S A Pru -> Ber
F Bel -> NTH
France:
A Wal S A Yor -> Lvp
F ENG S F Bel -> NTH
F Nap -> Apu
F NAF -> Tun
F WES S F NAF -> Tun
A Rom S A Ven H
A Ven H
England:
A Lvp H [fails, dislodged]
F Edi S A Lvp H [invalid order]
Italy:
NMR [A Tun holds]
Turkey:
F ION -> Apu [fails, bounced]
F AEG -> ION [fails, bounced]
F EAS S F AEG -> ION
F Con -> AEG [fails, bounced]
A Arm -> Smy
A Rum H
A Mos - Lvn
A War - Pru
A Sil S A War - Pru
A Swe H
F Nwy S A Swe
F Sev H
Austria:
A Tyr - Mun
A Boh S A Tyr - Mun
A Bul S F Gre
A Tri - Tyr
F Gre S A Bul
Germany:
A Yor - Lvp
A Mun - Tyr [fails, dislodged]
A Kie -> Swe [invalid order]
A Pru -> Ber
F BAL S A Pru -> Ber
F Bel -> NTH
France:
A Wal S A Yor -> Lvp
F ENG S F Bel -> NTH
F Nap -> Apu
F NAF -> Tun
F WES S F NAF -> Tun
A Rom S A Ven H
A Ven H
England:
A Lvp H [fails, dislodged]
F Edi S A Lvp H [invalid order]
Italy:
NMR [A Tun holds]
Turkey:
F ION -> Apu [fails, bounced]
F AEG -> ION [fails, bounced]
F EAS S F AEG -> ION
F Con -> AEG [fails, bounced]
A Arm -> Smy
A Rum H
It looks like we're heading into some warfare on all fronts! Multiple supply centers change fronts - Turkey loses both Bulgaria and Sevastopol, putting a serious dent into their plans this winter, while the Austrian front successfully enters Munich. It's not all doom and gloom for Germany, though, as they stop the bleeding by getting into Liverpool as England desperately tries to hold their home centers. Russia, meanwhile, bears down on the Kaiser's with Austria's support, while France gains a whopping 4 centers.
Italy (CrreamyKitty) has been eliminated. Thanks for playing, CK - it was a tough game for you once France went after you and you got your defenses completely removed. Hope you had a good time at least at the start of the game.
Germany (Alice Kazumi and M2H) and England (ImaginaryNeon), please submit your retreat orders for A Mun and A Lvp promptly. Once that happens, we move into Winter of 1904.
Disband me out of this farce
Winter 1904.
An exciting winter season as all the fronts begin to see bloodshed - how will this season's builds either strengthen a defense or ensure an attack? We'll have to see.
France [+2 builds] - gained Venice, Rome, Naples, and Tunis, but did not have to disband any units in Winter 1903
Austria [+2 builds] - gained Bulgaria and Munich
Germany [+1 build] - gained London and lost Munich, but had a unit forcibly disbanded last year
Russia [0 builds] - gained Sevastopol, but already had 6 units
England [0 builds] - lost Liverpool, but disbanded a unit this year
Turkey [-2 disbands] - lost Bulgaria and Sevastopol
Orders in by tomorrow at 7 PM EST (GMT-5).
Germany:
A Mun retreats to Ruh
England:
A Lvp disbands
A Mun retreats to Ruh
England:
A Lvp disbands
An exciting winter season as all the fronts begin to see bloodshed - how will this season's builds either strengthen a defense or ensure an attack? We'll have to see.
France [+2 builds] - gained Venice, Rome, Naples, and Tunis, but did not have to disband any units in Winter 1903
Austria [+2 builds] - gained Bulgaria and Munich
Germany [+1 build] - gained London and lost Munich, but had a unit forcibly disbanded last year
Russia [0 builds] - gained Sevastopol, but already had 6 units
England [0 builds] - lost Liverpool, but disbanded a unit this year
Turkey [-2 disbands] - lost Bulgaria and Sevastopol
Orders in by tomorrow at 7 PM EST (GMT-5).
Attachments
Last edited: