Honestly, I thought twilight princess was awesome. It took everything OOT did that I fell in love with and pushed it to the brink. The only reason I like OOT better is because I look at it with the rose-tinted glasses of nostalgia.
Also I'm playing through Phantom Hourglass right now and actually like it. The story leaves a bit to be desired (but then again, what portable zelda game didn't) but so far it's HARD AS BALLS! It's definatley one of the most difficult Zelda games I've played and I like that it's the first game I've seen truly utilize all of the DS's capabiliies.
And there you have it. Like you said TP took everything great about OoT and took it further.
Anyways, im redoing my list because the last one sucked due to my tiredness..
Still in no specific order.
Bahamuts Lagoon-
To this day Im hoping against hope that Nintendo finally makes it so I can play this game without having to play it on rom (I hate sitting on my computer for long enough to play Video Games). The story was interesting enough but the gameplay was fantastic!
Legend of Zelda- Majoras Mask and Twilight Princess
Majoras Mask had a great concept imo, and it worked out beautifully. TP gets the nod over OoT since its more or less the same, but better. Only real flaw for TP IMO was that damned temple where you had to direct that statue around..slowed the game down way too much.
Pokemon- Red/Crystal/Diamond
The fantastic sense of adventure, the thrill of the hunt..the healing my Pokemon 15 times in a roiw at the Pokecenter ebcause I thought theyd be stronger each time so I could beat misty (later I learned about typing advantages, leveling up,ect)
God of War 1+ 2
The insane amounts of brutatlity and violence were a first for me, the story is amazing in both games and the gameplay keeps it from getting boring.
Final Fantasy 8 + 9
They have the 2 greatest stories in any video game Ive ever played, 8s gameplay got a little boring for awhile (Draw. Draw.Draw.Draw) but overall the Junctioning system was really enjoyable while learning abilities from weapons and armor in 9 was something I really liked. I like FF 12 alot but not on the same level as 8/9 (fuck 7). 4 also gets a mention for being the first RPG I ever played.
Fire Emblem Series
I thoroughly enjoy all these games but no one really sticks out.
Shadow of the Colossus
One of the most epic feeling games Ive ever played, probably the best 15 hours of my life. Maybe not..>_>
Super Mario World
The first game I ever remember playing, I probably put as many hours into this as I did any other game besides Pokemon.
Assassins Creed
The first time I saw this game on Game Informer issue years ago I was as entranced by it as I was the first time I saw a pair of tits. Gameplay is repetetive after awhile but I typically only play it one assassination at a time to try and alleviate that.
I know theres something Im forgetting..