QuentinQuonce said:Been thinking about this since I saw it the other day. I don't think we've ever had a new evolution that worked like this but imo it'd be really cool to see, conceptually and mechanically. The middle stage could just be skipped entirely, with Scyther who become Kleavor having access to moves (and even perhaps abilities?) that Scizor who evolve directly from Scyther do not. It already works like this with babies, there's scope to do something similar with a middle evolution.
Actually what I think
Eriorguez meant was, stat-wise, Kleavor should have been inbetween Scyther & Scizor:
Scyther:
70/110/80/55/80/105//500
Kleavor's Actual Stats:
70/135/95/45/70/85//500
"Inbetweener" Kleavor:
70/120/90/55/80/85//500
Scizor:
70/130/100/55/80/65//500
But as for the concept you mentioned, it would have to be done with a Pokemon whose stats have a radical change either in numbers or distribution (also maybe a Type difference). However another issue also comes with the questions of why not just improve the previous evolution or just make this new "mid" stage a completely new evo with stats to match. Like I was trying to think of an example, was going to use Onix & Steelix, but before I got too far I thought "anything I'm thinking of is either a better Onix (thus they should just make Onix's stats better), a lesser Steelix (which means there's no point), or could just be an alternate Onix evo". I'm sure there's probably some Pokemon, but honestly I would just prefer either new evolutions or Baby Evos of Pokemon that could have a reasonable prevo made for it.
Hugin said:Don't forget that fairly often, Pokemon does major battles in
reverse matchup order. Paldea E4 is a perfect example, Ground>Steel>Flying>Dragon. In fact, looking through
the list, only Kanto!Indigo and Sinnoh don't have the members types in reverse order of who wins. There's some stretches, but it's clearly something they try to do.
My assumption has always been that Bruno's good enough to beat Koga even if Koga resists all his attacks(Onix SWEEP), while losing to Karen no matter how much damage he does to her Umbreon. Skill beating out type matchups.
Quoting
Hugin since they're the last one to mention anything about this topic, though I'm just adding my thoughts to the overall discussion than specifically responding to their post.
For the E4 who have a specific order, considering the rooms are customized to their Type (though wouldn't be surprised if they had a way to shuffle the rooms placement), I think they occasionally have matches against each other to decide order. I still argue they are equal in power and, at the end of the day, it doesn't matter in what order a League Challenger faces them in as they have to battle all E4 anyway. So the order is more for bragging rights between each other than their position on the League totem pole. Of course, as I mentioned in my last post on this subject, the "4th member" usually comes out on top whenever they do this, with Lance even going on to become a Champion.
Ashton98 said:I think the Hoenn region had too much water in it. I found it annoying to constantly keeping having to use surf when travelling in the games. And it could be easy to get lost when using surf, and you had to spend a lot of pokecoins on repel, since travelling by water meant lots of random encounters.
I think the problem with Hoenn's water route isn't that there's a lot of them, but rather they're all the same. The ocean has many different kind of biomes, both above and under water, they could have made the routes different from one another which would help break up the monotony of surfing on yet another water route. From one of my old posts on this very thread:
Pikachu315111 said:In addition the ocean is more than just open water. There are plenty of water biomes, especially when near land, which could have added some interesting visuals when exploring all the water routes. They could have had a coral reef, kelp forest, hydrothermal vents, brine pool, marine snow, algae bloom, ocean current, a sunken ship, a whale fall, a garbage patch, etc.. You then dot the area with trainers who, in addition to a battle, give you some information about the biome/phenomenon. And of course would help diversify what Pokemon you'd find.
CoralReaper707 said:I think we have too much water type aquatic creatures. Half of them don't even use water as elemental attacks. I'd go as far as to say some of the fish Pokemon would make sense as either part normal type, or even pure normal type.
They've actually gotten better with that over the years. Just look through the Water Egg Groups (
One (Terrestrial),
Two (Fish), &
Three (Invertebrates)).