NOC The Mafia Invitational (Game Thread) [D2 Deadline: Friday, March 2nd, 6 PM EST]

Status
Not open for further replies.
To be honest, I don't know if he made it explicitly with normal guidelines. This game is meant to be competitive though; Texas is not going to have a Godfather or other blacklisted normal roles. I say that with 100% confidence.
 
Texas-01/17/2018
I'm not sure, might have to talk to mastina about balance for a 15p or something. Want to find the right balance between player inclusion and sub availability assuming we shouldn't need many subs

versace-01/17/2018
15p is weird, but ms team mafia has 15p mini normal for inclusion all 12:3 so I assume they can do it

I would guess it means stronger mafia roles

Texas-01/17/2018
And a likely vig

versace-01/17/2018
maybe, vigs are bad for balance tbh

add a lot of swinf

swing

by normal standards

Texas-01/17/2018
I think if it's 17p I'd have something like 4 subs right

Even a OS vig

To get back to lylo

Vs mylo

versace-01/17/2018
12:3 vs 10:3 is just an extra lynch and nk

and 17p yea but I would hope we don't need subs itg

f larges -_-

Texas-01/17/2018
That's what I figure, people are confirming in so we shouldn't need subs so it's desirable to minimize the sub list

January 19, 2018

Texas-01/19/2018
Just confirming/reminding that you're still in the invitational :p

Mastina's setup wasn't what I was looking for really so I'm trying to figure out how to get a closed setup that is definitely good that I don't know so I can participate lol

Don't really want to have the game be open and devolve into claim fighting
Some relevant logs, the rest of the convo took place in random PTs and PS and shit so I don't have easily accessible logs.
 
Yeti said:
my only issue with the walrein wagon is that dle is also on it (or was) and dle disengaged and idling out feels like he went for lhf in someone else disengaged and idling out, but i wanted to tie them to see what happen. i think pushing wagons to be equally competitive (even if 1+ is town) can at least be informative.
Click to expand...

Good point here, but I'm leery about bungling our way into NL.
 
Can we focus more on the game though please? This doesn't help you sort my alignment or vice versa and it's day 1 so you can't hope to break the setup. 6 hours til deadline and the closest we are to a lynch is l-4.
 
Yeti said:
lol this is an historic smogon dot com mafia game

we're gonna flail wildly an hour out of eod to decide wagons
Click to expand...
as long as we don't turbo the doctor we're doing better than serenes forest dot net

wrt Knight's "someone being informed of a role existing would be broken" I've seen roles like this multiple times on SF, it's not inherently broken

now that we've established amrock is scum, do we lynch him? :blobthinking:

wrt Walrein I can also confirm he was playing league/slay the spire like 24/7 when he was my scumbuddy in a recent game

One thing that's nagging me about Josh v MetalSonic is Josh repeatedly saying Metal Sonic is lying, despite having a town leaning read on him (he mentions late in the argument that he's starting to think Sonic might be scum). Normally when someone I'm townreading is tunneling/scumreading me for bad reasons I don't think of them as liars, since that implies I think they have ill intent (aka are scum). When Josh was under fire in Cyberpunk Mafia because people thought he was a Robot I also felt like his word choice/tone was more in line with what I would expect from a villager who is super frustrated with a dumb case on them (I was dead during that debacle but I wasn't informed beyond knowing he was telling the truth about no Asek claim and I knew Walrein had been sheeted so the "only flyhn+MS on sheet both are scum" train was inaccurate, so I didn't for sure know he was town).

otoh I feel like DLE's posts were good, esp the part where he was going into work but still took the time to comment on recent events. I sort of feel like scum DLE would take the opportunity to just bail again?

Man maybe Josh is the best lynch today......
 
Josh said:
don't remember if i said this, if i did postgame is cool.


this is the classic FH i was excited for


so... lightwolf, maybe.


MS: you gave nearly the exact same lynchpool as me. Moody / DLE / Walrein / Yeti / FH. just want to muse.


Read it closer. Greylisted roles are allowed, FV is greylisted. Though really, its getting common enough its going to be whitelisted soon. Don't understand what 2) means.
Click to expand...
okay, so maybe you are town and I was derptunneling. I’ll review when I iso you, when I next get computer access, which will be in day 2

Let’s say you are town.

Who is most likely to be 3rd scum?

Also regarding fv:

Can I confirm if your fv gamebreaking strategy:

A) confirms FV as town, that means, they are town pregame and you know this
B) confirms FV’s alignment, that means, FV could be scum, but you’ll find out with your so called trick like a pseudo cop

Please reply a or b
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top