Originally Posted by Choutoshio
His Problem (and to a large degree Flare's and Rapidash's problem) is that he's a mono-fire type. :P
No second Stab (Boy does Arcanine wish he were fire/dragon) and weakness to afformentioned ROCK, water and ground weaknesses makes him a permanent bench-sitter despite great stats, coverage, and ability.
Swiftrunner, you're forgetting that I said that Arcanine's PROBLEM is a lack of a second stab to compliment his fire one. So, you can't really say that my arguement is unviable unless you say he'd still be crappy if he were a dragon/fire type.
Assuming Arcanine were a Dragon/Fire type with STAB Draco Meteor:
These calcs assume an even split of 126evs in both stats, Naughty, and Life Orb:
Stab Draco Meteor:
Salamence (0/0)-- lol 160%-190%
Garchomp (0/0)-- More lol 121%-140%
Tyranitar (0/0)-- 65.40% - 76.83% (Chance of 2HKO since Flare Blitze does 30.50% - 36.07%)
Swampert-- (252/0)-- 60.15% - 70.79% (Chance of a 2HKO since on the second round it still gets 30.45% - 35.64%)
Hippowdon-- 69.29% (252/0) - 81.67% (sure fire 2Hko since on the second go it still does 35.00% - 41.19%)
Cresselia (252/0, assuming DEF cresselia): 40.09% - 47.07%
. . . Not terribly pathetic . . .
So under the hypothetical situation that Arcanine was a Dragon/Fire with STAB'd Draco Meteor . . . He could theoretically dish out a shitload to everything on the list as it switches in if it carries:
-Draco Meteor
-Thunder Fang
-Flare Blitz
-Crunch/Hidden Power Ground
(You'd have to make a choice between killing Cress or Heatran . . .)
. . . but even under that hypothetical situation, you probably wouldn't do that. You'd probably do something like this:
-Draco Meteor
-Flare Bitz
-Extreme Speed
-Thunder Fang/Hidden Power something
Otherwise . . . he'll always be a bit sub-OU, like I said . . .
And sorry about the really off-topic tangent about Dragon/fire Arcanine in a thread about Flareon. >_>