2: utility is great and its speed tier is premium for what it's tasked to take on, but offensively is really inconsistent and often winds up feeling weaker in practice than it does on paper
I think the list is great, that being said you cannot convince me that Cinderace is lower than A+ in this meta, I'm sorry.
Okay you broke down offensive, supportive, and defensive presence. Supportive presence it's the only thing in this meta that puts on a fight when it comes to screens and webs which is currently dominating the meta, Cinderace Item of choice is Heavy-Duty Boots so it doesn't ever have to adapt it's game. Cinderace also doesn't have to be the only option on the team to move entry hazard it can be paired with a Rapid Spinner (Even though this is not related so I'll stop here). I personally think Cinderace in this current meta is top 5, purely because of the ability to Court Change when this covers a wide range when it comes to the builder in terms of preparing for Ribombee and Ninetales-Alola, switches in on it's attacks and threatens it with Court Change or Pyro Ball. Defensively it's not the best but you can run a more dedicated HP set, but it's great switching in on Gholdengo (Make it Rain) and taking advantage of the Court Change, and threatening it to switch out. Offensively, Libero / Blaze + Swords Dance and option to Sucker Punch, Gunk Shot, High Jump Kick, Zen Headbutt and other moves are still being under explored (It has a versatile movepool).
I agree, with Gliscor, Gholdengo, Kingambit and Great Tusk being better mons in terms of viability, but I don't think you can make an argument of any of the other mons except maybe Dragapult (Which is forced to run the HDB set) since how common Sticky Webs are (So it's usually limiting it to one set) because it needs massive support if it's running any other set to remove entry hazard. Zamazenta as well, I think the best set it runs is Leftovers + Substitute for Gliscor matchups, even though HDB is extremely viable with 4 attacks. Every other mon listed under A+ all falls victim to Sticky Webs which usually invalidates the matchup, you NEED support from Cinderace to make all these mons feel like a A+ mon.
Anyway thanks to Finch for hosting as project leader in the past, and thank you to the VR council for putting such effort in this.