A lot of people that seem to talk about altering species clause in it's current form are misguided in my opinion, because ultimately I think any Tiering Policy change on this level should have pro's that heavily outweigh the cons, with a focus on OverUsed, similarly to how the Sleep Clause was handled.
A change to the current clause has to be objective and clearly understandable, Alternator is the only one that has proposed a concrete implementable adjustment to the current clause, which doesn't absolutely decimate lower tiers by allowing multiple of Silvally, Pikachu or Oricorios.
I don't think allowing regional forms on the same team as their regular counterparts is worth the headache of going through every single instance of multiple forms.
If a concrete situation is proposed, it would have to differentiate between the following list of duplicate forms btw:
For what it's worth, following Alternator's suggestion would allow for the following forms to be run together in OU:
I honestly think this is the implementation method with the least negative repercutions from any solution proposed as it comes to combinations, but ultimately, what would we even gain from this?
The only OU Cores that would ever see any level of viability would be Zapdos+Zapdos-G, Moltres+Moltres-G, Ogerpon+Ogerpon-Cornerstone+Ogerpon-Wellspring. All the others would be incredibly gimmicky or straight up unviable in the current OU landscape.
Having more freedom is cool and all, but it becomes very complicated to the newer player as well to understand which forms they're allowed together, and which forms they're not.
A change to the current clause has to be objective and clearly understandable, Alternator is the only one that has proposed a concrete implementable adjustment to the current clause, which doesn't absolutely decimate lower tiers by allowing multiple of Silvally, Pikachu or Oricorios.
I don't think allowing regional forms on the same team as their regular counterparts is worth the headache of going through every single instance of multiple forms.
If a concrete situation is proposed, it would have to differentiate between the following list of duplicate forms btw:
For the purposes of this list, any Pokemon that is listed as a seperate physical Pokemon (typically with a different sprite), but share a Dex Number, this also uniquely focuses on gen 9 OU available Pokemon, ignoring old gens and Ubers, as well as mid-battle forms for the context of BH (which already has rules in place for this).
These are only for Pokemon with Concrete differences in Typing, Abilities, Stats or Movepool, these are the main objective criteria to go off, without including things like Pikachu Caps, Zarude forms, Gastrodon or others as well as even Gender Sprite Differences.
NON-REGIONAL
Tauros:
- Tauros-Paldea
- Tauros-Paldea-Aqua
- Tauros-Paldea-Blaze
Deoxys:
- Deoxys-Speed
- Deoxys-Defense
Rotom:
- Rotom
- Rotom-Heat
- Rotom-Wash
- Rotom-Frost
- Rotom-Fan
- Rotom-Mow
Arceus:
- All of them
Basculin:
- Basculin
- Basculin-Blue-Striped
- Basculin-White-Striped
Basculegion:
- Basculegion
- Basculegion-Female
Tornadus:
- Tornadus
- Tornadus-Therian
Thundurus:
- Thundurus
- Thundurus-Therian
Enamorus:
- Enamorus
- Enamorus-Therian
Keldeo:
- Keldeo
- Keldeo-Resolute
Vivillon:
- Vivillon
- Vivillon-Fancy
- Vivillon-Pokeball
Meowstic:
- Meowstic
- Meowstic-Female
Hoopa:
- Hoopa
- Hoopa-Unbound
Oricorio:
- Oricorio
- Oricorio-Pom-Pom
- Oricorio-Pa'u
- Oricorio-Sensu
Lycanroc:
- Lycanroc
- Lycanroc-Midnight
- Lycanroc-Dusk
Silvally:
- All of them
Toxtricity:
- Toxtricity
- Toxtricity-Low-Key
Indeedee:
- Indeedee
- Indeedee-Female
Oinkologne:
- Oinkologne
- Oinkologne-Female
Squawkabilly:
- Green and Blue
- Yellow and White
Ogerpon:
- Ogerpon
- Ogerpon-Wellspring
- Ogerpon-Hearthflame
- Ogerpon-Cornerstone
REGIONAL:
- Diglett
- Dugtrio
- Exeggutor
- Geodude
- Graveler
- Golem
- Grimer
- Muk
- Meowth-Alola
- Persian
- Raichu
- Sandshrew
- Sandslash
- Vulpix
- Ninetales
- Meowth-Galar
- Slowpoke
- Slowbro
- Slowking
- Weezing
- Articuno
- Zapdos
- Moltres
- Growlithe
- Arcanine
- Avalugg
- Braviary
- Decidueye
- Voltorb
- Electrode
- Sliggoo
- Goodra
- Lilligant
- Qwilfish
- Samurott
- Typhlosion
- Zorua
- Zoruark
- Wooper
- Tauros
These are only for Pokemon with Concrete differences in Typing, Abilities, Stats or Movepool, these are the main objective criteria to go off, without including things like Pikachu Caps, Zarude forms, Gastrodon or others as well as even Gender Sprite Differences.
NON-REGIONAL
Tauros:
- Tauros-Paldea
- Tauros-Paldea-Aqua
- Tauros-Paldea-Blaze
Deoxys:
- Deoxys-Speed
- Deoxys-Defense
Rotom:
- Rotom
- Rotom-Heat
- Rotom-Wash
- Rotom-Frost
- Rotom-Fan
- Rotom-Mow
Arceus:
- All of them
Basculin:
- Basculin
- Basculin-Blue-Striped
- Basculin-White-Striped
Basculegion:
- Basculegion
- Basculegion-Female
Tornadus:
- Tornadus
- Tornadus-Therian
Thundurus:
- Thundurus
- Thundurus-Therian
Enamorus:
- Enamorus
- Enamorus-Therian
Keldeo:
- Keldeo
- Keldeo-Resolute
Vivillon:
- Vivillon
- Vivillon-Fancy
- Vivillon-Pokeball
Meowstic:
- Meowstic
- Meowstic-Female
Hoopa:
- Hoopa
- Hoopa-Unbound
Oricorio:
- Oricorio
- Oricorio-Pom-Pom
- Oricorio-Pa'u
- Oricorio-Sensu
Lycanroc:
- Lycanroc
- Lycanroc-Midnight
- Lycanroc-Dusk
Silvally:
- All of them
Toxtricity:
- Toxtricity
- Toxtricity-Low-Key
Indeedee:
- Indeedee
- Indeedee-Female
Oinkologne:
- Oinkologne
- Oinkologne-Female
Squawkabilly:
- Green and Blue
- Yellow and White
Ogerpon:
- Ogerpon
- Ogerpon-Wellspring
- Ogerpon-Hearthflame
- Ogerpon-Cornerstone
REGIONAL:
- Diglett
- Dugtrio
- Exeggutor
- Geodude
- Graveler
- Golem
- Grimer
- Muk
- Meowth-Alola
- Persian
- Raichu
- Sandshrew
- Sandslash
- Vulpix
- Ninetales
- Meowth-Galar
- Slowpoke
- Slowbro
- Slowking
- Weezing
- Articuno
- Zapdos
- Moltres
- Growlithe
- Arcanine
- Avalugg
- Braviary
- Decidueye
- Voltorb
- Electrode
- Sliggoo
- Goodra
- Lilligant
- Qwilfish
- Samurott
- Typhlosion
- Zorua
- Zoruark
- Wooper
- Tauros
For what it's worth, following Alternator's suggestion would allow for the following forms to be run together in OU:
- Tauros, Tauros-Paldea, Tauros-Paldea-Blaze, Tauros-Paldea-Aqua
- Rotom, Rotom-Heat, Rotom-Wash, Rotom-Frost, Rotom-Fan, Rotom-Mow
- Basculin or Basculin-Blue-Stripe, Basculin-White-Stripe
- Tornadus, Tornadus-Therian
- Thundurus, Thundurus-Therian
- Enamorus, Enamorus-Therian
- Hoopa, Hoopa-Unbound
- Lycanroc, Lycanroc-Midnight, Lycanroc-Dusk
- Ogerpon, Ogerpon-Wellspring, Ogerpon-Cornerstone
- Diglett, Diglett-Alola
- Dugtrio, Dugtrio-Alola
- Exeggutor, Exeggutor-Alola
- Geodude, Geodude-Alola
- Graveler, Graveler-Alola
- Golem, Golem-Alola
- Grimer, Grimer-Alola
- Muk, Muk-Alola
- Meowth, Meowth-Alola, Meowth-Galar
- Persian, Persian-Alola
- Raichu, Raichu-Alola
- Sandshrew, Sandshrew-Alola
- Sandslash, Sandslash-Alola
- Vuplix, Vulpix-Alola
- Ninetales, Ninetales-Alola
- Slowpoke, Slowpoke-Galar
- Slowbro, Slowbro-Galar
- Slowking, Slowking-Galar
- Weezing, Weezing-Galar
- Articuno, Articuno-Galar
- Zapdos, Zapdos-Galar
- Moltres, Moltres-Galar
- Growlithe, Growlithe-Hisui
- Arcanine, Arcanine-Hisui
- Avalugg, Avalugg-Hisui
- Braviary, Braviary-Hisui
- Decidueye, Decidueye-Hisui
- Voltorb, Voltorb-Hisui
- Electrode, Electrode-Hisui
- Sliggoo, Sliggoo-Hisui
- Goodra, Goodra-Hisui
- Lilligant, Lilligant-Hisui
- Qwilfish, Qwilfish-Hisui
- Samurott, Samurott-Hisui
- Typhlosion, Typhlosion-Hisui
- Zorua, Zorua-Hisui
- Zoroark, Zoroark-Hisui
- Wooper, Wooper-Hisui
- Rotom, Rotom-Heat, Rotom-Wash, Rotom-Frost, Rotom-Fan, Rotom-Mow
- Basculin or Basculin-Blue-Stripe, Basculin-White-Stripe
- Tornadus, Tornadus-Therian
- Thundurus, Thundurus-Therian
- Enamorus, Enamorus-Therian
- Hoopa, Hoopa-Unbound
- Lycanroc, Lycanroc-Midnight, Lycanroc-Dusk
- Ogerpon, Ogerpon-Wellspring, Ogerpon-Cornerstone
- Diglett, Diglett-Alola
- Dugtrio, Dugtrio-Alola
- Exeggutor, Exeggutor-Alola
- Geodude, Geodude-Alola
- Graveler, Graveler-Alola
- Golem, Golem-Alola
- Grimer, Grimer-Alola
- Muk, Muk-Alola
- Meowth, Meowth-Alola, Meowth-Galar
- Persian, Persian-Alola
- Raichu, Raichu-Alola
- Sandshrew, Sandshrew-Alola
- Sandslash, Sandslash-Alola
- Vuplix, Vulpix-Alola
- Ninetales, Ninetales-Alola
- Slowpoke, Slowpoke-Galar
- Slowbro, Slowbro-Galar
- Slowking, Slowking-Galar
- Weezing, Weezing-Galar
- Articuno, Articuno-Galar
- Zapdos, Zapdos-Galar
- Moltres, Moltres-Galar
- Growlithe, Growlithe-Hisui
- Arcanine, Arcanine-Hisui
- Avalugg, Avalugg-Hisui
- Braviary, Braviary-Hisui
- Decidueye, Decidueye-Hisui
- Voltorb, Voltorb-Hisui
- Electrode, Electrode-Hisui
- Sliggoo, Sliggoo-Hisui
- Goodra, Goodra-Hisui
- Lilligant, Lilligant-Hisui
- Qwilfish, Qwilfish-Hisui
- Samurott, Samurott-Hisui
- Typhlosion, Typhlosion-Hisui
- Zorua, Zorua-Hisui
- Zoroark, Zoroark-Hisui
- Wooper, Wooper-Hisui
I honestly think this is the implementation method with the least negative repercutions from any solution proposed as it comes to combinations, but ultimately, what would we even gain from this?
The only OU Cores that would ever see any level of viability would be Zapdos+Zapdos-G, Moltres+Moltres-G, Ogerpon+Ogerpon-Cornerstone+Ogerpon-Wellspring. All the others would be incredibly gimmicky or straight up unviable in the current OU landscape.
Having more freedom is cool and all, but it becomes very complicated to the newer player as well to understand which forms they're allowed together, and which forms they're not.
Last edited: