Oh watch out, he's such a badass.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
Smogon University PO Statistics — March 2012
- Thread starter Antar
- Start date
- Status
Oh watch out, he's such a badass.
Isn't it funny that sand veil is on 49.8 percent of Gliscors in the 1337 statistics and Gliscor is on over 15.9 percent of teams, so it is on 7.95 percent of teams, but it clearly isn't broken right? I mean you have a 5% increase in useage from regular useage to 1337 usage.
Hoping there's double sarcasm in here, because 7.95% isn't a lot lol
Couldn't we just ban Sand Veil once all the Pokemon who can "only have Sand Veil" get their DW baility released (I believe only Sandslash is left)? To be honest, it is just as "bad" as the other evasion moves, except that there are some Pokemon who previously only had Sand Veil as their ability that made banning ti a bad idea. Hell, considering no one cares about Sandslash, it probably wouldn't be that bad now.
Why ban something that is not broken?.............Why should pokemon lose move pool options over something not broken?
Sub SD Gliscor is every bit comparable to Garchomp in terms of what it can set up on, its counters, and the number checks that disappear when the have to worry about it being under a Sub at +2 and missing. The fact that people are using this strategy to such great success on the ladder just sickens me. Regardless of what you say, facing similar garbage like this and losing a key Pokemon to a dice roll that you could not avoid is the exact opposite of fun, healthy, and competitive.
I guess I am just too terrible, because I have never lost a game this generation due to sand veil abuse from Gliscor.
@SJCrew: The exact same thing can be said about critical hits, paralysis, confusion, etc.
They aren't really the same. To paralyze or confuse, certain moves must be used. And there are legit counters, such as type immunity, switching out of confusion, heal bell, rest, occasionally lum berry (no miss moves are not legit counters). If all else fails, you can bring the paralyzed pokemon out to avoid further hax. But sand veil is passive, its always in effect, and you can't remove yourself from the situation by a simple switch. Even a phazing move has a chance to miss, and your opponent can always bring the abuser back later. I'd also like to say that there is no current problem with critical hit abuse, and normal critical hits are not a choice of the player like using sand veil is. I am by no mean the most articulate endorser of this point. There are much more convincing versions of this argument, but the point remains that sand veil is not exactly equivalent to other hax.
We don't have prominent examples of Pokemon being banned primarily for critical hits, paralysis, or confusion, but we definitely threw the book at the forerunners for Evasion abuse. Really, I don't understand why people bother making that silly leap in logic when there are ways to heal status effects, but not ways to heal an 80% chance to miss all of my normally accurate moves.
You can excuse critical hits as it evens out those lesser-used pokemon, as much as it makes Draco Meteors/Outrages/Close Combats/Hydro Pumps seem impossible to withstand; remember RBY the ratio was much higher, and attacks such as Slash would crit. every turn. 6.65% is managable and fair to even things out in terms of strength.
A critical hit from Gliscor after just one Swords Dance will make one your pokemon faint "just like that". It's not difficult to use something such as Trick to lock your opponent into one attacking move, and bring in Gliscor when you can Substitute freely. You have to take each battle as it comes, and I feel this meme was strongly felt during Garchomp during 4th Gen.
Paralysis and confusion are moves which usually don't come with powerful moves outside of Hurricane and Thunder, though in reality a potential sweep is not on the cards just because they're confused/paralyzed. In Gliscor's case, you're at the mercy of it behind Substitute if you don't have Skarmory.
Anyway, it seems I have more success evading Terrakion Stone Edges using Sand Veil, more than I ever would using Poison Heal and whitnessing Terrakion Stone Edge me to death because chances are Earthquake won't OHKO and they may have Rock Gem/Air Balloon w/ Substitute.
A critical hit from Gliscor after just one Swords Dance will make one your pokemon faint "just like that". It's not difficult to use something such as Trick to lock your opponent into one attacking move, and bring in Gliscor when you can Substitute freely. You have to take each battle as it comes, and I feel this meme was strongly felt during Garchomp during 4th Gen.
Paralysis and confusion are moves which usually don't come with powerful moves outside of Hurricane and Thunder, though in reality a potential sweep is not on the cards just because they're confused/paralyzed. In Gliscor's case, you're at the mercy of it behind Substitute if you don't have Skarmory.
Anyway, it seems I have more success evading Terrakion Stone Edges using Sand Veil, more than I ever would using Poison Heal and whitnessing Terrakion Stone Edge me to death because chances are Earthquake won't OHKO and they may have Rock Gem/Air Balloon w/ Substitute.
It is kinda annoying when people go on about no way to counter Sand Veil, you could change the weather, that you know removes this passive effect that always is magically in play. I disagree with this whole ban this thing because it is competitive, ban something for being broken and the number have been shown before, it is not broken. But after this post I am just going to shut up before this whole thing goes into the cycle that it did in the mega thread before.
Why do people only care about SV? Because it's a bit more common than snow cloak? That thing is just as stupid. It's just really annoying not to hit with 100 % accurate moves. :/
More often then not you're pretty much screwed if you need your counter to that Pokemon to even break a sub in the first place (or you just miss). It is always so match-deciding in my battles to miss because of those abilities. >_<
Mamoswine and Gliscor are so threatening with these abilities. I wish Garchomp would be OU again since it's not really too different from these in my opinion (and the metagame has more fast Pokemon too since DPP and very many Pokemon already have ice type moves for the already threatening Dragons so it doesn't seem to me he'd be overpowered).
Miss-stuff is just really stupid in itself.
And it is different from crits, since if you're faster you can still hit your opponent... but to miss with 100% acc moves? There's just nothing you can do except pray. It won't always be happening, but when it does it is really broken.
More often then not you're pretty much screwed if you need your counter to that Pokemon to even break a sub in the first place (or you just miss). It is always so match-deciding in my battles to miss because of those abilities. >_<
Mamoswine and Gliscor are so threatening with these abilities. I wish Garchomp would be OU again since it's not really too different from these in my opinion (and the metagame has more fast Pokemon too since DPP and very many Pokemon already have ice type moves for the already threatening Dragons so it doesn't seem to me he'd be overpowered).
Miss-stuff is just really stupid in itself.
And it is different from crits, since if you're faster you can still hit your opponent... but to miss with 100% acc moves? There's just nothing you can do except pray. It won't always be happening, but when it does it is really broken.
Actually, Garchomp is pretty different from those two since A) Sand is a lot more common than Hail and B) Gliscor is mostly a defensive Pokemon while Garchomp is more offensive. Garchomp is also really powerful even without Sand Veil; SV makes it too powerful to contend with in the normal OU metagame. If you want OU Garchomp, play Dream World.
I know Acrobatics makes a world of Difference, but then why is it healthy in Gen IV? Sub/SD/EQ/SE still, while not quite as good, has all the issues that "sicken" you due to Sand Veil.
So why is it only Gen V, the Generation with many, many more checks and counters to Sand Veil mons (mainly in the form of competing weather), that Sand Veil is now a "sickening" ability? What is this double standard? Why don't we go back and Ban Sand Veil in Gen IV as well, seeing nothing has changed between the two generations in how it can be abused?
From personal experience, (I am not sure if the stats back me) I saw MORE sand veil abuse in gen 4 with the popularity of baton pass gliscor, then gen 5. I was also much worse then too.
I guess it can be argued that those were inferior players then, and now we have more serious players using it, making the 2 situations seperate. But then again few people are over 1377, lets be real now.
I guess it can be argued that those were inferior players then, and now we have more serious players using it, making the 2 situations seperate. But then again few people are over 1377, lets be real now.
the one thing that's better about Sand veil abuse this gen that makes it less irksome is that Brightpower is banned. But yeah, losing a battle you should win because of a Sand Veil miss is pure bullshit imo. You can change the weather, sure, but in the lower tiers where sand is the only permanent weather, that's not quite as easy. OU is less of an issue, but Sand Veil abuse is still present.
I'm not getting into this debate (at least not now, I guess), but one can tell a "bs hax" in BW is much worse than in DPPt simply because teams have to be airtight nowadays. "Bs hax" is almost unbearable this generation, and Gliscor being an asshole really doesn't help anyone.
I find it silly to even suggest, if need be, banning/restricting those abilities using the Evasion Clause though, exactly because they never mattered before BW, except for maybe Garchomp being a dick, and Evasion Clause goes all the way back to RBY.
Okay what the hell is this nonsense o_0
Blissey's EV spreads:
We have ridiculously powerful special attackers in the tier and you're telling me that you're not running SpD EVs? I can excuse Chansey for running such a set because she gets +1 SpD, but not Blissey. If you want to see your Blissey get 2HKOed by Specs Politoed's Hydro Pump go right ahead. 252 HP / 252 SpD is even more ridiculous, since Blissey would have no physical bulk whatsoever and you're nearly OHKOed by Tyranitar's Pursuit IIRC.
Blissey's EV spreads:
We have ridiculously powerful special attackers in the tier and you're telling me that you're not running SpD EVs? I can excuse Chansey for running such a set because she gets +1 SpD, but not Blissey. If you want to see your Blissey get 2HKOed by Specs Politoed's Hydro Pump go right ahead. 252 HP / 252 SpD is even more ridiculous, since Blissey would have no physical bulk whatsoever and you're nearly OHKOed by Tyranitar's Pursuit IIRC.
Sand viel should not be banned because with gliscor one miss doesn't mean it will sweep you're team it is not as powerful or as fast a chomp, even at 2 it struggles to break through physical walls it cant even use toxic to break through skarm, hell as shown in one thread at +2 gliscor and 2ko an air balloon magikarp
lol
thats barely even an argument, basically what you say is only a few games get ruined because of sand veil, and to quit whining about the hax
1/5 is a huge chance actually, when you consider that every move now has the accuracy of stone edge (and no one ever loses games because of that move..) and the fact that sand veil gliscor is an offensive sweeper that can do huge damage if given a free turn. All it takes is one untimely miss and its game over. Not to mention that missing 100% accuracy moves due to a PASSIVE ability that doesnt require any setup is just plain disgusting. Also using "weather" to counter sand veil is a poor argument as switching in your weather inducer requires a turn, just what that gliscor was looking for when it was subbing. I sincerely hope someone reopens the gliscor suspect discussion whether for all users or just for tiering leaders because gliscor brings an unhealthy and uncompetetive aspect of luck into the metagame.
My god I thought we had settled this. I'm guessing most of you didn't read my arguments in the actual official thread for this... Seriously, if you are serious about this, look up the thread in the topic and read my arguments. Those took me hours to write out so I'm not going to repeat them here, but seriously... this is an issue to people?
Let me compare it to something that's VERY comparable; DD Gyarados using Waterfall. A 20% chance of a flinch... and if that flinch is on your counter, you lose. And yet, I have not ONCE heard anyone complain about that. And I've honestly had that happen several times more to me than SV hax. I'm not saying it should be banned (not even remotely), I'm saying there are similar versions of hax out there and we usually just, y'know, live with it. It's Pokemon. And believe it or not, it's Smogon policy that we should not go to extreme lengths to remove luck elements from the game. Look it up, it's in the CODM!
Now, I'm getting out of this argument. I've made my case before, and I'm 90% certain I won that case (or we'd have a ban by now). Bitch and complain all you want, but you're going to have to live with it.
Let me compare it to something that's VERY comparable; DD Gyarados using Waterfall. A 20% chance of a flinch... and if that flinch is on your counter, you lose. And yet, I have not ONCE heard anyone complain about that. And I've honestly had that happen several times more to me than SV hax. I'm not saying it should be banned (not even remotely), I'm saying there are similar versions of hax out there and we usually just, y'know, live with it. It's Pokemon. And believe it or not, it's Smogon policy that we should not go to extreme lengths to remove luck elements from the game. Look it up, it's in the CODM!
Now, I'm getting out of this argument. I've made my case before, and I'm 90% certain I won that case (or we'd have a ban by now). Bitch and complain all you want, but you're going to have to live with it.
- Status