NOC Smogon Rewind Night 3

[Laurel]

Why this > clarinets?

I think Clarinet is town here

 

[VigilanteVigoroth]

bad read, this is drookez's personality.

It’s way more than his personality imo. Reveals He has something to share, reveals he has a result, reveals he watched the dead person, reveals his result.

 

[Drookez]

I like dropping clues slowly because it makes me seem more important than I really am

 

[Former]

Town (In order of playerlist)
Energy
Rad
XX
Drook
KOC

Likely Town
CB
TBZ
Whydon

Nullish
U-Turn

Probable scum
VigVig
Clarinet

Likely Scum
M2H
Apricity

I'm lazy and not going to do reasons for each read because that takes awhile. But if you want to know about a specific one, ask

 

[VigilanteVigoroth]

Ok nvm drooky is too adorable to sr he’s locktown

 

[Former]

But uh yeah. Vigvig being the one to publicly doubt drook actually adds authenticity to drook's claims lol

 

[VigilanteVigoroth]

But uh yeah. Vigvig being the one to publicly doubt drook actually adds authenticity to drook's claims lol

Not doubting his results. Was doubting if they were from a town watcher

 

[Former]

Not doubting his results. Was doubting if they were from a town watcher

 

[Panic Station]

tryna catch up but I'm doing mod stuff as well, so it's slow going

 

[Laurel]

apricity Former

if hal is right and maf 1-shot gravedigger exists and you take my 1-shot and kill me ill go baby rage mode

 

[Panic Station]

Reading 1961 and finally somebody made a fucking case in this game

 

[Panic Station]

It's also worth mentioning that Former knew he was going to get tunneled before D2 even started

Can you cite sources here that aren't Hal?

 

[Panic Station]

It's a nitpick yes, but I want to see how much early traction Hal's screaming had.

 

[apricity]

Christ.

 

[apricity]

Now I’m put in a position of having to choose between two people who were in my lynch pool that I don’t have strong confidence on

while former lives another day

 

[apricity]

Wow this result is fucking awful

 

[apricity]

MewtwoHidden Clarinet claim roles

 

[Panic Station]

Oh god, did Drookez actually claim after I told him further claims would help scum pick the NK?

 

[Panic Station]

Hi Hal, if you could take the time to answer that questionnaire I slipped under your door when I came in...

 

[apricity]

Hi Hal, if you could take the time to answer that questionnaire I slipped under your door when I came in...

I see literally no benefit in talking to you. I know your alignment, you have trouble arriving at the simplest conclusions in this game so I can’t possibly understand what benefit there is in me interacting with you

 

[Former]

Former is far from confirmed town, and I think there's a high chance of him being scum here.

In #1584, he first hints at his role being something that can clear multiple people, and thinks it's "lock town." Obviously, this is extremely powerful. If he truly believes that, it's weird how he tries to imply that he's a town protective role in #1377 in order to "eat a nightkill", mentioned in post #1747. Later, he backtracks and gives a completely different reason when Rad asks him the same question: because he felt like it and to see hal's reaction (#1758). Is he backtracking because he knows how little sense he makes, or because he caught his own slip? I'm assuming that Former played the entire D2 thinking that his role was extremely strong, so why would he want to bait the kill? This is a really incriminating slip.

I didn't really want to respond to this post because a lot of it is just awful. But I want to help you see why this particular part is awful. You say it's a slip, but you don't connect it to any scum reasoning. You bring up my points about "eating a night kill" and "seeing hal's reactions" like they're mutually exclusive. But no, I had both reasons when I did it.

I've also never said my role was really strong (because it's not, it's strength is based on what other town people have). And if other people have strong stuff, then it's better for me to be night killed because then the kill isn't on people with the strong stuff.

But most importantly, you bring up that I "slipped" but you don't have the justification. You posted something you think doesn't make sense, but that doesn't equal a slip. For something to be a slip, you have to connect it to why it's something mafia or 3p would do. Just saying "I don't understand this thing" doesn't mean it's something mafia would do.

 

[Panic Station]

I see literally no benefit in talking to you. I know your alignment, you have trouble arriving at the simplest conclusions in this game so I can’t possibly understand what benefit there is in me interacting with you

I'm not fully caught up yet and my mind tried to consider the possiblities of your tunnel this morning and went in two different directions on it. Please let me sort you?

 

[Panic Station]

I know my reads are incorrect somewhere, I just wanna make sure the spot isn't you.

 

[Panic Station]

I'm siting here with Drookez/Vig/Mewtwo as POE and I'm not confident in it.

 

[apricity]

apricity A few questions.

1) What happens if Former flips Town?
2) What did you get out of asking me the deets of my PR?
3) What do you think scum's chances are of winning with a parity buffer in the game?

If former flips town then I have been more wrong this game than I have ever been on this site. I will probably blame Texas for no reason

I just forgot what your role was

scums chances of winning are determined by how well we can lynch obvious scum. So far they are not looking so good