It's finally here, I've been waiting for this one
I'm not as experienced as some people here, but I feel that it's not as overcentralizing that it's been made out to be.
It's not the only pokemon that can be considered impossible to counter by balance/offense(kyuB and victini are examples of powerful wallbreakers without many real counters) so there have to be other qualifications that would make this OP. Rock polish may set it up for that
The setup turn for RP is a crucial thing to note, as it's rare that a pokemon will setup more than once in a game- against offense it's extremely difficult to get a free turn at all without a play. Even after it, azumarill, ice sharders, and talonflame can revenge it pretty easily. Most teams have at least 1 pokemon that can take a hit from a set, and because it only has 1-2 slots to play around with, teams which have 2-3 pokemon who can take an earth power can generally take it on somewhat well as long as they keep their team healthy.
Before it gets up a rock polish, it's laughably easy to check-almost anything faster can kill with relative ease, and speed creep has determined that outspeeding a base 101 pokemon isn't the most difficult thing to do
I can accept that it's an S rank threat, but a ban seems to imply that it can sweep any offense or balance team unconditionally, and it can't. To ban it without first pointing a finger at things like mega charizard X, mega altaria, and even bisharp(who can sweep most offensive teams after subtracting a mon and does quite well vs balance) feels hypocritical.
I'm not as experienced as some people here, but I feel that it's not as overcentralizing that it's been made out to be.
It's not the only pokemon that can be considered impossible to counter by balance/offense(kyuB and victini are examples of powerful wallbreakers without many real counters) so there have to be other qualifications that would make this OP. Rock polish may set it up for that
The setup turn for RP is a crucial thing to note, as it's rare that a pokemon will setup more than once in a game- against offense it's extremely difficult to get a free turn at all without a play. Even after it, azumarill, ice sharders, and talonflame can revenge it pretty easily. Most teams have at least 1 pokemon that can take a hit from a set, and because it only has 1-2 slots to play around with, teams which have 2-3 pokemon who can take an earth power can generally take it on somewhat well as long as they keep their team healthy.
Before it gets up a rock polish, it's laughably easy to check-almost anything faster can kill with relative ease, and speed creep has determined that outspeeding a base 101 pokemon isn't the most difficult thing to do
I can accept that it's an S rank threat, but a ban seems to imply that it can sweep any offense or balance team unconditionally, and it can't. To ban it without first pointing a finger at things like mega charizard X, mega altaria, and even bisharp(who can sweep most offensive teams after subtracting a mon and does quite well vs balance) feels hypocritical.