Slowbro actually checks things such as Mega Lop, Garchomp, Medi, etc
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen8nationaldex-593483Slowbro right now is very bad imo and functionally doesnt check a lot of the stuff its supposed to, running ice beam to be able to check chomp means giving up one of scald or future sight since +2 eq will break you fast and mega chomp with HP can even sub up on slowbros uninvested scald slowbros version of checking chomp is typically taking +2 252 Atk Garchomp-Mega Earthquake vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Slowbro: 270-318 (68.5 - 80.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO from an EQ then teleporting into something that can actually check it since even ice beam 0 SpA Slowbro Ice Beam vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Garchomp-Mega: 272-320 (76.1 - 89.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO wont kill in 1 either
Medi Just powers directly through with tpunch
252+ Atk Pure Power Medicham-Mega Thunder Punch vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Slowbro: 204-240 (51.7 - 60.9%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
and bro switching in to lop is typically forced to slack off on a u turn or get 3hkod by return which leaves bro vulnerable to being setup on by pup encore variants of lop.
Pads Melmetal bullies this thing too 252+ Atk Iron Fist Melmetal Thunder Punch vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Slowbro: 158-186 (40.1 - 47.2%) -- guaranteed 3HKO you tpunch or even twave on switch then all it takes is one dib flinch and bro is gone
Blaziken also eats through this with Lorb sets or Electrium Z
+2 252+ Atk Life Orb Blaziken Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Slowbro: 385-455 (97.7 - 115.4%) -- 87.5% chance to OHKO
On top of being a fake check to a lot of stuff it looks like it should wall slowbro is very exploitable and can and will be subbed up on by extremely common mons such as Serp, Kyurem, Magnezone, forced out by pivots like Rillaboom, Greninja and Tapu Koko or get setup on by things that can easily rip through a team like SD Weavile, Mega Gyara, Mega Latias, Volcarona and Kartana.
Slowbro definitely deserves a drop
Can i get the team by any chance if you don't mindhttps://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen8nationaldex-593483
This replay alone disproves just about everything you said. Slowbro was the MVP, and it's positive traits shine against both chomp and Lop here. Without Slowbro I can't position my breakers the way I did without perfect prediction on aggressive double switches. My opponent even admitted he didn't click Axel vs glisc because of my slowbro in the back. In hindsight it should've been ice beam but either way Slowbro put in work and it does this pretty reliably against various team structures
Slowbro isn't the beast it is in SS, but it has more than enough positive traits to keep it in the A ranks. It's perfectly fine where it is.
Can i get the team by any chance if you don't mind
UR --> C
Regular Pert trades the water immunes of Gasto and Seis in exchange for having both Rocks and a pivoting move, and I believe this is rankworthy. It can just be a general nuisance to a lot of teams and tends to be a very decent rocker. While it lacks some of the defenses and power of Mega Pert, it can make up for this with 3 different viable item choices, being standard lefties, Icium z to lure grounds and potentially something like a chipped lati or tang, and Z Refresh, which not only heals Pert of status, but fully recovers its HP. I've used it quite a bit on ladder (albiet with a UU team) and have found it to be decently solid.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1461217419-4rg7jo3i9rigg12mfm20452ttjuz03wpw A good showcase of swampert being annoying
Despite Mega Charizard Y being eternally walled by Blissey, as well as not doing nearly enough to Toxapex, isn't it better than B tier? Since Mega Charizard's power is so immense, I believe it would still be worth it to use, and better than Pokemon like Tapu Bulu, especially because it puts quite a large strain in teambuilding, given that one would have to use Blissey in order to be completely safe against Charizard.
The Pokemon I'm even more confused about is Mega Charizard X. Despite the meta being hostile to it, it has even less counterplay than Mega Charizard Y in my opinion. In fact, most of the A and S ranked Pokemon would fall quickly to either its dual STABs or Earthquake, and it even appeared in a former version of the sample teams. Therefore, I would like to ask, what makes Charizard X to be unranked?
I would be grateful if a more experienced player could give their input on this.
Zard X is an incredible mon in this slow ass meta rn and definitely deserves to be tiered, Ive been running a fire spam with it and it absolutely shreds through teams in sun, you do not need roost because not every team has to be BO/balance you run can absolutely run 3atk in sun and destroy practically all checks, getting 2-3 kills and dying to flare blitz recoil is not a bad thing. on top of that if youre edgy you can run greeedy Xard belly drum scale shot sets with quick attack priority to pray on people switching into Zard Y checks, +6 quick attack will actually ohko most shit faster than a Xard like Koko, Greninja, Lopunny, Weavile, Etc. The meta is super weak to Zard X right now especially considering most of you lack speed control faster than a +1 Base 100. No rocks are not an issue for any competently built Zard X team especially not an issue that makes it UR worthy while Zard Y is ranked. you can play around rocks especially by trading more threatening hazards like webs screens and tspikes or running dual hazard removal. When taking belly drum sets into consideration, there is not a single mon I could find in the calculator that can switchin to Zard X absolutely none. there is a set that breaks everything Zard X is the definition of viable since there is not a single team that carries checks to every Zard X set the closest things to a check to this beast are the unaware walls, Physdef Quagsire which is 2hkod by outrage or can be by dragon claw + 1 layer of spikes or flare blitz in sun +1 layer of spikes. Full physdef Pyukumuku is the other which is not only not used but gets 2hko'd by adamant thunder punch anyways.
Heres some replays of it tearing shit up
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1450888784-ihxgglrjzf4vu53jjbmxm0tggx3dz0apw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1479319822-7btf0ntqzqwm94qeeez95u7ftw4ex7qpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1480437870-av134hcmutqmczzgdz20e5aejtg0s0npw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1478494967-unxldq450dximdvh7oy5j56xczj553jpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1477884138-2q2po73mxe67vukf8p295n5ahq3j5dqpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1474062221-4zmkmw9z4t4kbr1f1bz92rciai64g44pw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1450882313-2vzbxf7yx35eq0jrwzqygq31g1jf0popw
Brought it to Fall Seasonal vs Stareal and Sendoh10
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1460362160-yzgx9kbuaolvbh6kyozh8f7mdh29jbjpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1458422689-neyw4igqivxvnwe1o8lme0tsgqasj4spw
Nomming to B at minimum.
Zard X is an incredible mon in this slow ass meta rn and definitely deserves to be tiered, Ive been running a fire spam with it and it absolutely shreds through teams in sun, you do not need roost because not every team has to be BO/balance you run can absolutely run 3atk in sun and destroy practically all checks, getting 2-3 kills and dying to flare blitz recoil is not a bad thing. on top of that if youre edgy you can run greeedy Xard belly drum scale shot sets with quick attack priority to pray on people switching into Zard Y checks, +6 quick attack will actually ohko most shit faster than a Xard like Koko, Greninja, Lopunny, Weavile, Etc. The meta is super weak to Zard X right now especially considering most of you lack speed control faster than a +1 Base 100. No rocks are not an issue for any competently built Zard X team especially not an issue that makes it UR worthy while Zard Y is ranked. you can play around rocks especially by trading more threatening hazards like webs screens and tspikes or running dual hazard removal. When taking belly drum sets into consideration, there is not a single mon I could find in the calculator that can switchin to Zard X absolutely none. there is a set that breaks everything Zard X is the definition of viable since there is not a single team that carries checks to every Zard X set the closest things to a check to this beast are the unaware walls, Physdef Quagsire which is 2hkod by outrage or can be by dragon claw + 1 layer of spikes or flare blitz in sun +1 layer of spikes. Full physdef Pyukumuku is the other which is not only not used but gets 2hko'd by adamant thunder punch anyways.
Heres some replays of it tearing shit up
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1450888784-ihxgglrjzf4vu53jjbmxm0tggx3dz0apw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1479319822-7btf0ntqzqwm94qeeez95u7ftw4ex7qpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1480437870-av134hcmutqmczzgdz20e5aejtg0s0npw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1478494967-unxldq450dximdvh7oy5j56xczj553jpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1477884138-2q2po73mxe67vukf8p295n5ahq3j5dqpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1474062221-4zmkmw9z4t4kbr1f1bz92rciai64g44pw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1450882313-2vzbxf7yx35eq0jrwzqygq31g1jf0popw
Brought it to Fall Seasonal vs Stareal and Sendoh10
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1460362160-yzgx9kbuaolvbh6kyozh8f7mdh29jbjpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nationaldex-1458422689-neyw4igqivxvnwe1o8lme0tsgqasj4spw
Nomming to B at minimum.
I'd just like to note that blaziken with firium z could pull off similar stunts while having better instant power (and de facto speed if using protect), which would avoid wasting a mega slot and having a rocks neutrality rather than a weakness. Also, utterly dominating ttar whilst forcing a ko on stuff like latias without requiring specific coverage moves is always excellent.
Edit: Also punishing the hell out of pursuit is always nice
B -> B+
He goes hard. Guaranteed crits and immunity to protect scouting makes this a great no nonsense mon that can come in and threaten most of the tier with great coverage on its dual stab types. Usually you can go u-turn to pivot out of the bad Toxapex matchup, but tpunch works as well since this mon pairs nicely with u-turn Tapu Koko. Aqua jet is decently strong priority and especially useful for checking Volcarona. I would never use anything other than banded on this mon. A lot of the time you just click buttons and kill something and you're only choosing between your two stab types. Definitely a mon that is better and more self-sufficient than B ranked stuff like Arctozolt and Hawlucha.
-> A+ Kyurem is literally impossible to safely switch into, between its 6 (yes, 6: SubRoost, Specs, Sub DD, NMI, Z move 3A, and Choice Scarf) different sets which all have vastly different counterplay makes it almost impossible to check consistently. Your Kyurem check is SpDef Corv? Get Specs Ice Beamed. Using Blissey to tank that? get 1v1d by Sub DD. Maybe you're offensively pressuring it with Mega Lopunny or Ash-Greninja, get scarf freeze-dried, its just a stupid pokemon to play around, as well as one of the biggest threats in the builder, and to reflect this it should be A+
Just want to mention Clef fails to check Sub DD because it gets PP stalled. Also you can't say there's no reason to distinguish NMI and Specs, being able to Roost and switch moves does mean NMI has very different counterplay in practice than Specs, all you really have to do to keep Specs in check is keep Rocks up and pivot around it. You can't do this with NMI, which is exactly why it's such a dangerous set.Don't completely disagree with this nom, but there are a few things I'd like to say.
"Its 6 (yes, 6: SubRoost, Specs, Sub DD, NMI, Z move 3A, and Choice Scarf) different sets which all have vastly different counterplay makes it almost impossible to check consistently".
This statement isn't entirely wrong but I do feel it's a little misleading. Imo there's little reason to distinguish Icium, Specs, and NMI from each other, especially since the checks/counters to those sets tend to mostly overlap. Specs Kyurem has lost a lot of relevance too (though ladder still seems to love it). Scarf Kyurem also doesn't really exist and Freeze Dry doesn't kill lop either. While it does excel vs specific builds, Sub DD is pretty rare and is arguably just a matchup fish.
I'd also like to dispute your claim that Kyurem is "literally impossible to safely switch into". While there probably isn't any single relevant Pokemon that can switch into every possible set, one can usually tell what set the Kyurem is running and many fat structures naturally run checks to sets that one's primary check can't deal with.
Checks/Counters
This mon can reliably counter every Kyurem set with the exception of specs Draco.
Decent check that switches into Specs, NMI, Icium, Scarf, and can also thaw itself with Scald. Can 1v1 SubRoost depending on sets and evs. Team structures that this mon fits on are likely naturally carrying a Sub DD check anyway.
Solid check to every Kyurem set except those running specs Focus Blast. Won't deny that it can be worn down though.
Counters every Kyurem set except Specs HP Fire and Icium.
Checks Sub DD and SubRoost.
Counters Sub DD, SubRoost, Scarf, and Icium (after Z has been used). Can also use Kyurem as set up fodder with Calm Mind.
Counters Specs, NMI, Icium and Scarf. Like Glowking, team structures that Blissey fits on usually carry a natural check to Sub Kyurem anyway.
Iron Head Ferro is a usable short-term check to NMI and Scarf.
Spdef Corv checks NMI, Icium, and Scarf.
Spdef checks every set except Specs.
Arguably an unmon but in my opinion it does have a niche. Checks Scarf, Icium, NMI.
Yes, before anyone brings it up, I realise most of these mons can just be frozen and haxed through. Really don't think that's a solid argument for these mons not being defensive answers though since it's highly luck dependent and the capacity to hax past its checks isn't unique to Kyurem.
Now, on another topic, I think Tapu Koko should rise to A+. It can be an absolute pain to dance around and keep from gaining momentum, as well as excelling vs Lando/Fini/Tran cores rn. Many players neglect to bring a solid Electric check and rely on Lando as their sole ground which Koko can readily exploit, especially with the development of non-specs sets easing prediction.
Just want to mention Clef fails to check Sub DD because it gets PP stalled.
Also you can't say there's no reason to distinguish NMI and Specs, being able to Roost and switch moves does mean NMI has very different counterplay in practice than Specs, all you really have to do to keep Specs in check is keep Rocks up and pivot around it. You can't do this with NMI, which is exactly why it's such a dangerous set.
Yes other mons can hax their checks, but none of them have the ability to fish for hax over the course of a game like Kyurem can. Freeze Dry has 32 PP. That's a lot of potential freezes, and Kyurem has the longevity to use that PP. So most of these mons can't realistically consistently check any special Kyurem set that has longevity. And when you look at how small this list is to begin with, you see how strong Kyurem really is. I support Kyurem to A+.
It does depend on your spread, as DD Kyurem can invest in as whatever bulk it feels like depending on your team. Specially Defensive Dragon Dance exists to beat most Clef (and also Heatran), as it only gets 3HKOed by unboosted LO Moonblast:Pretty sure CM clef checks Sub DD, especially if Unaware. Maybe we're thinking of different sets and EVs (like lefties + protect whatever).
But you still have to respect the possibility of Specs Focus Blast nuking you to high heaven when you first switch in an answer. NMI is the better set, agreed, but trying to dismiss one set or the other as having the same counterplay is just incorrect. NMI actually has answers that don't fold to one correct prediction, but the challenge is making that counterplay outlast Kyurem, whereas with Specs you're just trying to keep the beast at bay until it wears itself out.I think you misunderstood what I meant there, so maybe I should have been more clear. I'm not saying that Specs is better than NMI. My main intention there was arguing that Specs is both irrelevant and also easy to play around enough that one should usually just consider NMI and Icium (which are actually very similar in terms of defensive checks with the exception of MScizor being hit by HP fire on Icium). Lol I agree with you on NMI being much better than Specs.
NMI also has inarguably more switch-ins than Specs, so if anything, it being a more popular set actually supports my argument that Kyurem isn't "literally impossible to switch into".
Kyurem has frankly amazing bulk for a breaker, and Roost mitigates Rocks.Eh I think you overestimate Kyurem's longevity, especially with that rocks weakness. Freeze Dry's 32 PP is also pretty irrelevant for the non pressure stalling sets it runs so bringing that up is mostly a moot point I feel.