NOC Low Power Mafia -- Mafia Win

realiti said:
TOWNCORE
Nuxl: Very difficult to fake this level of engagement and solving attempt as scum

des: Very difficult to fake this level of engagement and solving attempt as scum

TOWNLEAN
JALMONT: Hard to see why scum!JALMONT would engage so heavily D2 in a dead thread, his posts seem to come from genuine thought and curiosity

Skipper: I’ve played with both town!Skipper & mafia!Skipper, his playstyle was drastically different between alignments and I correctly read him both times. He normally dodges the thread as scum and is sporadic as town, IMO he is strongly in his town meta this game

Flandrs: Good D1 posting IMO, strong thread presence when he was active. Liked his initiative and the interaction with JALMONT (don’t see why you’d antagonize him as town). Pretty blunt and to-the-point posting, which I associate more with town than scum (who normally try to word things in non-committal manners). However, he is below JALMONT and skipper because I don’t know his meta and he doesn’t have many reads.

SCUMLEAN
Duskfall98: I liked his earlier posts where he was casually tossing out town reads, thought that he wasn't forcing an agenda which I associate with his scum play. But I don’t like his push on Neon, it comes out of nowhere during a lull in the thread. Neon is a sporadic player and it’s hard to see why Tommy would pop in and go “THIS is the one scum read I have,” especially when he knows about Neon’s history. I understand the other Neon voters who couldn't think of better options, but Tommy's push seems opportunistic. Also don’t like his D2 entrance, he says he’s tilted but just waves off the vote and disappears - feels like he’s trying to pretend to be annoyed but doesn’t actually care.

DbD: Early CK tunnel D1 was fine, but then CK continues to flood the thread and DbD doesn’t re-evaluate the slot or interact with her posts. Seems like a lazy scumread made to avoid giving actual reads - I do this a lot as scum as well

Lechen: Don’t like his D1 progression, meh entrance -> scum reading two easy targets. Ironically I can apply his scumread on skipper to Lechen himself, seems like he’s throwing shade that doesn’t hurt his rep. Backtracking on the CK vote later was pretty towny IMO, but he goes back to the CK vote D2 which I found confusing.

SCUMCORE
Not enough happening to have someone here. This is my new term for players that I end up tunneling.
Click to expand...
Actually so maybe JALMONT is the best vote (there’s no way the Neon vote is all pure)
 
Nuxl said:
may I ask why you voted realiti
Click to expand...
hi yes

i said this earlier, but from reading the thread at the time that i voted, realiti's wagon made sense to me. them excluding m2h from their initial readslist while seeming to focus on them within the thread was what sold me the most - like why would you put all that effort into making a readslist and completely exclude someone you've clearly been engaging with? that and the fact that they got super combative towards the end, it read less desperate townie and more throw everything at the wall imo

putting my vote on anyone else (who was receiving votes at the time) made far less sense to me, as i didn't really feel strongly about NE, and being the sole vote on someone different would just. be stupid LOL
 
cheerful-choco.gif
 
realiti:
was against Bellringer claim, who proposed it, again?
agrees with duskfall voting dbd, but doesn't join in. Later votes M2H
supports Duskfall again.
Argues Crreamy shouldn't assume people voting him are town. That'd be me and dbd.
Argues in favor of Nuxl, Duskfall, flandrs, and a bit of Skipper and AP
Bunch of fluff
Calls out Duskfall and Alice for scumreading him later, I think when the vote on him has started.

CONCLUSION:
The push was enough for me to move CK in my reads from scumlean to null.
Duskfall probably bussed realiti when there wasn't really any saving him.
##Vote: Duskfall98
 
Aura Guardian said:
realiti:
was against Bellringer claim, who proposed it, again?
agrees with duskfall voting dbd, but doesn't join in. Later votes M2H
supports Duskfall again.
Argues Crreamy shouldn't assume people voting him are town. That'd be me and dbd.
Argues in favor of Nuxl, Duskfall, flandrs, and a bit of Skipper and AP
Bunch of fluff
Calls out Duskfall and Alice for scumreading him later, I think when the vote on him has started.

CONCLUSION:
The push was enough for me to move CK in my reads from scumlean to null.
Duskfall probably bussed realiti when there wasn't really any saving him.
##Vote: Duskfall98
Click to expand...
what the fuck?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top