...? :O
Oh wait, Frost, lol I thought you meant Rotom-Fan and I spent a minute or two with my mouth wide open. I disagree, mostly because it relies on Hail to operate, and has Fighting weakness. Nice for the Steel neutrality though.
Sounds like C rank material to me then. I've never used it, but the phrase "it has a niche" describes C rank mons pretty well.
Is the scarf set similar to Rotom-W's (ie Blizzard/Volt Switch/Hidden Power/Trick)? Or, since bolt beam is enough on its own, do you go for something else instead of hidden power?
I'm not saying it's as good as Kyurem for BlizzSpam, but the BoltBeam STAB, the Levitate, and the ability to run a great Scarf set, or a slower Chople/Occa set give it a specific niche in hail. It also gets Volt Swicth for those shenanigans.
Well, that's what the write-ups are for. In the write-up it will say something like "Rotom-Frost is great in hail; unfortunately it fairs poorly in other, more common weathers" or somesuch, and if people read it they will stick it on their hail teams. In addition, having it in C rank is probably more likely to make people use it than not listing it.
Not that other Rotom-formes bar Wash is used that much anyway, even if Frost-tom boasts having the only dual-targeting move.
i'd like to move gallade out of d rank and into c rank. the main reason being is that it's a trick room setter that can ohko ttar right through its chople and kyurem-b as well as having neato moves like feint, ice punch, helping hand and zen headbutt. i recognize the fact that its affected by intimidate and it can be (somewhat) easily checked by cress, but its like chandelure in that its power makes trick room that much more efficient, which is important because after your first trick room, you're not guaranteed another setup most of the time and you've only got 4 turns to work with. hell, it might even be better than chand in that regard because feint goes a long way in preventing double protect stalling. 'lade is solid c rank material imo, all things considered (it's definitely not down there with grotle, that's for sure)
also nominating riolu for d rank because father needs to be reunited with son, and its follow me is the fastest in the game, allowing it to redirect any fake out and basically guarantee a trick room setup. after that, it dies easily, allowing another 'mon to come in to abuse trick room. it also gets feint (again) and the neat anti-meta priority sunny day.
I did mention the possibility for Tailwind on Dragonite since both its abilities aid it nicely in that role, so there's that.Dragonite, down from B to C. We discussed it a while back and none of us could come up with a role where it was the best. The rain special attacking set is outclassed by Kingdra, Latios is the go-to dragon for Draco Meteor spam, and a bulky paralysis-spreading role is better done by Gyarados. Extremespeed is nice but there are more powerful priority attacks around that can actually hit stuff super-effectively, such as Bisharp's Sucker Punch and Breloom's Mach Punch. Therefore C because it is okay but outclassed.
Nollan and I have now done our 20 write-ups on the pad, and I am going on holiday tomorrow. Looking forward to seeing everything QC'd and submitted when I come back. ;)
Now I'm not nominating Reuni for B because I agree with those flaws, but saying Cress outclasses Reuni just because it has Ice Beam means you're completely ignoring Reuni's higher Special Attack, Magic Guard + LO for even more power, and Focus Blast so T-Tar doesn't shit on you (and it's slower than Cress).I don't agree with Reuniclus for A Rank, because 1) it is weak to all the things typical setters are weak to, and 2) only has 110/75/85 bulk, which while decent with investment, its not going to enjoy Dark Pulses off of Hydreigon, Night Slashes off of Bisharp, etc. The issue with Reuniclus is that it is incredibly predictable, it is always going to be setting Trick Room. Other common setters, like Chandelure, might be running Imprison + Trick Room, or maybe Scarf, but for Reuniclus, it is always the same. Not to mention Cresselia outclasses it to a solid extent at offensive Trick Room due to Ice Beam access. I vote Reuniclus stays at B.