-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Animal Mafia ~Game Over~
- Thread starter Metal Sonic
- Start date
- Status
Weird yes. Alignment indicative, no.
I mean, I don't see any situation where someone does that (of either alignment) and then vanishes. Like, if you are scum and have that claim, capitalize on it. But if you make that claim and then vanish, like, so what. It's poor play for either alignment, but it doesn't really indicate one over the other.
I mean, I don't see any situation where someone does that (of either alignment) and then vanishes. Like, if you are scum and have that claim, capitalize on it. But if you make that claim and then vanish, like, so what. It's poor play for either alignment, but it doesn't really indicate one over the other.
I'd vote FH but give him some more time to respond/actually do promised isos so he has no excuse
Where did I defend him? Last time I checked saying something someone did is NAI isn't the same thing as saying don't lynch this person. And like I believe I said back then, I did think it was weird that someone would ignore their result/the result publicly stated in the thread but I don't see that as plasuable for either alignment. Trust me though, if jordan had been more active, I would have pressed him on that. But he wasn't and so frankly there wasn't anything I could do on that front except for trying to read things that had actual bearings
Vote Former Hope
GG Jalmont if you are scum.
GG Jalmont if you are scum.
If I end up missing here or getting mislynched, sorry guys.
Put my heart and soul into this one and it just wasn't meant to be. You guys can yell at me postgame for issues about my process.
Put my heart and soul into this one and it just wasn't meant to be. You guys can yell at me postgame for issues about my process.
heavy breathing
The weird thing is that looking back, I can now see why you wouldn't want to insta-lynch xnad there. see: aprcitiy - but then once you get supposed confirmation, how do you not go back on that (and see what I was trying to say the whole time...)
The defense was implicit - you continually defended him by suggesting that we shouldn't lynch until we're sure he's mafia, we shouldn't vote him because he's afk and we should wait for him to defend himself, appeal to emotion surrounding "omg you're voting someone who could be the town cop!!!!"
You also make sure to state that "I'm not defending Jordan I just disagree with the logic!!!" which is scummy. for me. why the need to have a big show regarding your thoughts on jordan? that strikes me as odd.
the issue isn't even necessarily about why xnad did what he did - what i dont understand is your behavior in defending him. it's simply not logical to go from a half-assed accusation on xnad, to not changing ur thoughts after you got "host confirmation," to flat out defending him when people recognized this contradiction
we know (aka I know because I was redirected) that you lied about that host confirmation anyways, since i didn't/people do not get notified when redirected. why didn't you recognize this as happening to xnad? what explanation do you have for that?
The defense was implicit - you continually defended him by suggesting that we shouldn't lynch until we're sure he's mafia, we shouldn't vote him because he's afk and we should wait for him to defend himself, appeal to emotion surrounding "omg you're voting someone who could be the town cop!!!!"
You also make sure to state that "I'm not defending Jordan I just disagree with the logic!!!" which is scummy. for me. why the need to have a big show regarding your thoughts on jordan? that strikes me as odd.
lying about your action is not NAI - lying about your action is what you do as mafia. i dont understand how you can say this after claiming that the hosts told you that you get a result upon being redirectedfh said:
the issue isn't even necessarily about why xnad did what he did - what i dont understand is your behavior in defending him. it's simply not logical to go from a half-assed accusation on xnad, to not changing ur thoughts after you got "host confirmation," to flat out defending him when people recognized this contradiction
we know (aka I know because I was redirected) that you lied about that host confirmation anyways, since i didn't/people do not get notified when redirected. why didn't you recognize this as happening to xnad? what explanation do you have for that?
i still don't understand what this means - doesn't that mean xnad would've gotten a notice? he was cop, so he should've gotten info back that he was redirected no?
WHEW Jalmont is town
Awesome, I'm busy for the next two weeks too!
Well, we've crossvoted Jalmont
Reread and make a decision; I know that FH is scum but you don't
At this point my goal and his goal is essentially the same, which is to convince you to lynch the other. I recommend placing little weight on what we say from here on out and focus on reading back, because our goals aren't the same for those Days and you can discern mindset from them.
I'll be around if you need any questions answered but tldr - May the better side prevail.
Reread and make a decision; I know that FH is scum but you don't
At this point my goal and his goal is essentially the same, which is to convince you to lynch the other. I recommend placing little weight on what we say from here on out and focus on reading back, because our goals aren't the same for those Days and you can discern mindset from them.
I'll be around if you need any questions answered but tldr - May the better side prevail.
*twiddles thumbs*
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
can people post plz
can people post plz
sounds good
would still vote FH
AMA
literally just waiting for jalmont to vote FH here
- Status
Similar threads
