I'm not sure we can call a verdict on TIK, I'm not convinced he's our best voting target today. Being wrong about the structure of the village can be a huge tell, but that's a really bold mistake to make and I'm not sure he would say the same thing
Ullar has yet to make an intelligent/reasonable post itg
I don't like that von brought up outside-the-game behavior recently to defend himself, his arguments have been kind of flimsy and he's the kind of user who would know when his arguments are flimsy.
There are two users I want to call out though that have not been getting enough heat. The first is
Upside, who posted once attempting to clarify the rules. This is the least contentious post imaginable - one that would seem like a good idea from the mafia perspective. Nobody gets angry at you, etc. When I was mafia in Walrein's NOC game I did exactly the same thing. Seem helpful, and they won't suspect you. Well, I suspect you.
The second is
Flamestrike who called me out. He is also attempting desperately to make posts that won't make anyone angry. His posts have a lot of defense in them even though nobody has been attacking him other than Agape for like half a post. "Thanks for speaking up!" he says in response to the person he called out's post. Being nice != being village, and in this case I think it's indicative that he doesn't want to make anyone angry at him, similar to Upside, which is a scum thing to do. I can elaborate on this but will choose not to until he responds.