Lets not take this so seriously guys, its a fun forum challenge.
Besides the point of these threads is not really to educate people - there are analyses for that - but more a place to mix established ideas with propose some differing points of view. People should be able to submit known, hard counters if they want, or suggest things they've been messing around with if they can sufficiently defend it as viable.
re: The "1500 rule" is a bit fast and loose, if it helps consider it like this - if you are specifically going through RU / NU / NFEs and designing weird sets to specifically beat this one Pokemon, thats not really helping. We don't want this to degenerate to Shedinja winning every single week the victim doesn't have coverage for it, or people nominating CB Sucker Punch Cacnea as their Latios check. If you've got a weird pick that you could justify building a semi-serious team with though, then its fair game - heck I've used Kadabra, Ghost Rotom, Nidoqueen, Crustle, Quagsire to name but a few in the last 12 months.
I will admit the Throh submission did tread close to that line but the set posted is done better by Conkeldurr like every single time, though some other Throh set might have been able to stay as a serious submission. Still, lets try not to be killjoys over this stuff otherwise threads like this die quickly