Why Pokemon Gold/Silver are better than Crystal

DAWNBUSTER

UUPL Champion
Pokemon Gold / Silver are better than Pokemon Crystal. I know, I know, that is a hot take. Pokemon Crystal is basically just Gold/Silver but better! Crystal has the best sprites (they are even animated!), you can play as a girl, the evolution stone issue is fixed, there is a battle tower, a move tutor, etc etc. However, Pokemon Crystal is missing something from Gold/Silver. Something big. Something crucial. And no, it is not Mareep.

In the Gold and Silver edition of Burned Tower, there are three trainers. These include your rival and a trainer by the name of Firebreather Ned. However, the third trainer is who I wanna focus on. There is a third trainer by the name of Firebreather “Dick. Firebreather “Dick”, is an excellently designed trainer. He has a Lv 17 Charmeleon, a Pokemon sure to challenge you at this point in the game. This Charmeleon has the perfect movepool and level this point in the game, and a Charmeleon makes perfect sense for Burned Tower. Firebreather “Dick” is an excellent and memorable trainer. Most people I have talked to that have played Gold/Silver have called Firebreather “Dick” a memorable trainer for his well designed battle and other factors. Firebreather Dick is not just great game design, he even has a personality. After you beat him, he says be got burned out, and to to with that they change his overworld sprite to Gray. That is funny, man! The fact that they changed his appearance truly shows how much effort went into this trainer. Fuck Red, Firebreather “Dick” is Gold and Silvers masterpiece battle.

In Pokemon Crystal, Firebreather Ned and Firebreather “Dick” were removed. This is assinine game design. Firebreather Ned was Ok, but Firebreather “Dick” was an excellent challenge and wonderful guy. Every time I play Crystal and reach Burned Tower, I am over come with disappointment when I realise Firebreather “Dick” is nowhere to be found. The removal of Firebreather ”Dick” alone makes Crystal worse than GS for me.

Also, Heart Gold and Soul Silver fuck it up even more. They actually BROUGHT BACK Firebreather Ned…but Firebreather “Dick” was renamed to Richard? What the fuck? Who is this Richard jackass? Game Freak seriously tried to remove the legacy of Gold and Silvers best trainer. People say Pokemon has been going down hill since (INSERT GAME), but it has really been going down since 2000. This is when Game Freak decided to nuke their games best trainers.
 
Technically, Dick is an nickname for Richard, so they are the same NPC, although i agree the namechange of Firebreather Dick was Gamefreak's lowest point ever.
 
Technically, Dick is an nickname for Richard, so they are the same NPC, although i agree the namechange of Firebreather Dick was Gamefreak's lowest point ever.

How is Dick short for Richard? That doesn't make any sense.

I think OP had it right when she said the games went downhill after Game Freak added the ability to play as a girl.
 
Last edited:
How is Dick short for Richard? That doesn't make any sense.

I think OP had it right when he said the games went downhill after Game Freak added the ability to play as a girl.
According to my research, people in old times used to come with nicknames which rhyme eachother, so from Rick it came Dick, and Rick comes from Richard. This form of making names was called “knee bone connected to the thigh bone” type progression.
 
Screenshot_20231222-162857.jpg
Screenshot_20231222-162915.jpg



Need I say more?
 
In Pokemon Crystal, Firebreather Ned and Firebreather “Dick” were removed. This is assinine game design. Firebreather Ned was Ok, but Firebreather “Dick” was an excellent challenge and wonderful guy. Every time I play Crystal and reach Burned Tower, I am over come with disappointment when I realise Firebreather “Dick” is nowhere to be found. The removal of Firebreather ”Dick” alone makes Crystal worse than GS for me.
You can't spell assinine without assassin...


Oh wait.
 
Back
Top