Was it really only a week ago that I made nominations? Oh well, I've got more:
Toxapex: Drop from A- to B+
Clodsire: Rise from B+ to A-
Talking about these two together because they're kind of switching places.
Toxapex usage has plummeted, at least compared to the sort of reputation this thing generally holds. I know this thing has a lot going for it, but it ultimately boils down to one simple thing:
losing Scald has devastated its viability. Scald was its glue move, turning the joke back on Taunt users and checks trying to switch into it. Every turn was a potential chance for it to ruin your cycle and make the rest of the match an exercise in misery. Without Scald, Toxapex lacks that critical ingredient that transformed it from being just another really hard-to-kill wall to a powerhouse of insanity-inducing survivability. Now, its just as vulnerable to Taunt as many other tanks, and it is nigh powerless against the many powerful Steel-types running around in the meta. It had a brief stint as a Wo-Chien partner, but Wo-Chien can function just fine without it. Now, I think it would be crazy to drop it much lower than B, but as long as it lacks a suitable Scald-like, its golden days are likely well behind it.
Clodsire, on the other hand, is experiencing some renewed popularity. For one, it can actually
do something offensively to things like Flutter Mane, Gholdengo and Iron Moth with Earthquake. Turns out that being a special wall (good ones tend to be rarer than good physical walls from what I've noticed) with good typing, physical coverage and consistent recovery is a premium combination of attributes to have. Then let's combine that with two great abilities, Yawn + hazards support and Tera making it an absolute pain to deal with. While I think it can still suffer from a lot of the problems that passive mons like Toxapex has, its fits into this meta much more smoothly as the "unkillable blob" teammate.
Slither Wing: Drop from B+ to B-
Sorry Pearl, but I get the feeling you'd probably agree here. On paper, Fighting / Bug should be really strong in a Ruin-dominant meta. Unfortunately, none of the top 3 (Flutter Mane, Gholdengo and Dragonite) are Ruins, and they all check Slither Wing's STAB combo just by existing. This means building a team's resources around Slither Wing so that it
might work. I'd like to think that this guy has something to contribute, but until someone unlocks those cosmic secrets Slither Wing just isn't doing much right now.
Bellibolt: Drop from B+ to B
I still don't know much about this guy, but that's kinda the point. Where is it? I don't think I've ever faced one in the last two months. Its usage has fallen out of the top 50. I'm not the most informed about this mon, but I feel like its obvious that it isn't a B+ mon anymore. I'll be conservative and drop it to B for now.
Brute Bonnet: Drop from B+ to B-
I may not know much about this mon, but I can talk about it being in a very crowded pool of excellent Grass-types. Breloom, Meowscarada and Wo-Chien are all phenomenal right now. Amoonguss is also solid, and Arboliva has been on the rise. What does Brute Bonnet do that makes it worth using over any of these? The answer seems to be "not much" if its #70 usage is anything to go by. In fact, I would guess its the other Grass-type competition that is devastating its setup niche since there are so many strong Spore immunities running around right now. Simply put, its been cannabalized by its competition and is barely hanging on right now. A big drop is warranted.
Arboliva: Rise from B- to B
I will admit that wanting to move Arboliva out of the same tier as Brute Bonnet was a motivation for this--which I think is fair, because they are absolutely not in the same league--but what pushed me over the edge on this one was the rise of Tera Electric. Simply put, Tera Electric dunks on Gholdengo in a way that few Pokemon can, which you can see me explain in a recent dex update for Arboliva. I think we are going to need to see more results before it can go much higher, but its been making some waves for awhile now so I have some confidence in putting this nomination up.
Gardevoir: Rise from B- to B
This is the true sleeper of the current regulation if you ask me. Its already got some great set diversity and has the tools to trade into some of the meta's biggest hitters. Its not dominating in the same way the top 10 are, but its stellar balance of stats, STAB types and support moves make it a very unpredictable and capable trader into a large list of threats. As I've said for other Pokemon before: if you're laser focused on what you want it to do and where you want to use it, its super capable of making big value plays. That being said, I would not at all be surprised to see this thing make its way up to the A tier in the near future, because its matchup spread is truly impressive.
Floatzel: Rise from UR to C
While I don't consider this a particularly egregious omission, I do think it deserves a spot in the VR. Rain is at least acknowledged as a usable mode, even if its more of a low- or mid-ladder strategy these days. Floatzel is basically "Palafin at home," to use an expression that's popular among BSS vets. It trades needing Rain to operate well for not having to switch in and out to be at maximum power. Plus, having the fastest Wave Crash in the game is nothing to sneeze at. Its got a nice niche for itself as an alternative Rain abuser to Palafin, and it is the #3 teammate for Pelipper (below Palafin and Gholdengo.) If Pelipper gets representation, I think its most prominent Rain abusers should as well, so I definitely think Floatzel should sneak into the bottom of the VR list.