-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2024 Smog Awards!
Melee Tier List Discussion
- Thread starter Mia [old]
- Start date
![Mia [old]](/forums/data/avatars/m/17/17136.jpg?1387813379){kind=avatar}
Omg. Those were the days when the girls were good. D:
And Hi smogon I'm back! ^__^; Miss me!? <3
And Hi smogon I'm back! ^__^; Miss me!? <3
Wow, Jiggs is way up there now. Poor Samus, though.
The rest seems pretty accurate. Though personally I think Ness should be a bit higher.
I also don't think Pichu is at the bottom. Should be Kirby.
The rest seems pretty accurate. Though personally I think Ness should be a bit higher.
I also don't think Pichu is at the bottom. Should be Kirby.
If you honestly believe that you are stupid.
It is possible for a character to drop that far, just like how a character can rise from bottom to top.
Melee and Brawl are different games with different physics.
Captain Falcon was not only nerfed, he now has to deal with Brawl physics and the new characters. Something which he can not do.
OMG THIS PROVES G&WATCH IS NOT HIGH TIER. HE WAS BAD IN ANOTHER GAME.
Really Shaky, I doubt the Smash Back Roomers just put him at last without a reason. He has almost no redeeming qualities. You may think Ganondorf is worse but Ganondorf can kill characters in 4 hits, and has Ganoncide. Meanwhile he can tech chase with his Side-B.
anyone who knows like any jiggs players at all knows that mango is a beast. moving on...
the list seems incredibly balanced, which is obviously good. i have no objections with it.
the list seems incredibly balanced, which is obviously good. i have no objections with it.
Back when I didn't yet know of competitive Melee, I mained Roy, Yoshi, and Pikachu.
At least Mewtwo beats two characters on the list.
At least Mewtwo beats two characters on the list.
CF I always thought was underrated (Middle tier? Come on), so the slight bump is welcome.
What are those numbers? Are they secret back room code (Like the rest of the back room, ugh), or are they like based on wins or something?
Mario and Dr. Mario I didn't think we're really that different; other than better pills and slightly longer cape I thought they were effectively the same. DrM was better though, pillrushing was awesome.
What are those numbers? Are they secret back room code (Like the rest of the back room, ugh), or are they like based on wins or something?
Mario and Dr. Mario I didn't think we're really that different; other than better pills and slightly longer cape I thought they were effectively the same. DrM was better though, pillrushing was awesome.
I always knew Pichu would eventually end up at the bottom. Poor thing.
I'm in agreement with the list, but I always thought Sheik would pull ahead of Marth and Falco, but I'm not a member of the SBR, so my opinion doesn't hold much water. I also expected Kirby to be higher, I don't think Mewtwo is better.
I still love Mewtwo and use him as one of my secondaries though. I haven't played Melee for a while, tried last night, absolutely could not get the hang of it.
I'm in agreement with the list, but I always thought Sheik would pull ahead of Marth and Falco, but I'm not a member of the SBR, so my opinion doesn't hold much water. I also expected Kirby to be higher, I don't think Mewtwo is better.
I still love Mewtwo and use him as one of my secondaries though. I haven't played Melee for a while, tried last night, absolutely could not get the hang of it.
Yet Link still remains to be shit. They had fucking three games to get his shit right. :(
dude all they'd have to do is fix his fall speed and recovery and suddenly he'd be like mid tier.
interesting that a melee tier list comes out now with brawl in full force and melee kind of on the decline. and i guess there will be no more changes to the melee list?
Marth and Falco did not change much on the tier list. Although Falco has a different playstyle.