So, it's sad that this has to be necessary, but this is going to be a post about plagiarism.
For those who don't know, there's a
Gen VII GBA sprite project on PokéCommunity, which, like the Gen VI project hosted there, is a continuation of Chaos Rush's completed Gen I-V GBA sprite resource. The project largely consists of low-quality resizes of other artists' sprites, including many by
leparagon and
fishBowlSoul and some by
Wobblebuns and
Layell. For some time, we've been concerned with the project's poor crediting practices, namely incomplete or inaccurate credits in individuals' posts. Earlier this week, Layell
lodged a complaint in the thread, prompting a moderator to step in and directly address the problems with permission and crediting. Regardless, the state of affairs hasn't improved very much since; in particular, the OP's list of credits is insufficient and not organized in any sort of logical manner, such as contributors' usernames in alphabetical order or Dex order, with sprites from outside sources clearly highlighted.
Next, if it isn't surprising that a bunch of 15 year olds on the internet couldn't get crediting right, maybe an established, online content aggregator with a fanbase numbering in the millions absolutely would, right?
Two weeks ago, Dorkly published a Sun/Moon parody video on their YouTube channel featuring a number of BW-style fan sprites, including
TrainerSplash's
Mimikyu sprite, without giving credit. Splash wrote a letter to one of their personnel indicating that his sprite was not to be used without permission and requesting to be credited in the video's description. They responded to him in a timely fashion and ultimately complied with his request.
It would be lovely if the story ended there, but today,
aXl pointed out that Dorkly has published a "part two" to the above video using Splash's Mimikyu alongside other fan sprites. Even better, this time, they credited only Splash and not anyone else, such as
leparagon for his
Alolan Raticate sprite. The other fan sprites from the video appear to be the work of
JaegerLucciano23 on DeviantArt, who is also uncredited.
Without mincing words, it's disappointing to see that this is a recurring issue. Although Dorkly might operate in the realm of comedy, for small-time fan artists whose work is stolen, it frankly isn't funny (if crediting fan artists is that much of a sore point, they might consider taking a cue from us and pouring their blood and tears into producing their own custom sprites). If you're reading this, we ask that you consider writing to Dorkly about their improper handling of artists' work, as we very much hope to prevent this kind of thing from happening again in the future, even to artists unaffiliated with Smogon. The message you send need not be long as long as it's clear and uses courteous, non-inflammatory language.
At the Smogon sprite project(s), we take the issue of crediting seriously. In particular, the Sun/Moon project's application system means that the possibility of plagiarism transpiring here should be minimal, as each of the project's formal contributors are vetted for our artistic ability and integrity. That aside, a small number of this project's sprites are appropriated from outside sources, namely DA, and Layell not only credits third-party artists clearly on the spreadsheet but also often goes the extra mile by asking artists for written permission to use their work.