Okay, so I'm sorry in advance if that sounds rude, but the council has been showing either a clear lack of interest or competence lately.
Take the end of BW, Tornadus-T was broken as heck, the metagame was dominated by Rain in a way I've yet to experience again.
Obviously, what happened, is that a suspect with Tornadus-T and Keldeo took place. It was probably questionable to throw Keldeo into the mix, but most people did not really mind, and jumped on the occasion to give Tornadus-T the boot.
Where am I getting at ?
Few months later, after this suspect, the council decided to run another suspect, about Keldeo only. Why ? Because obviously the results of the previous suspect, as far as Keldeo was concerned, got probably skewed by the presence of the main offender at the time (Tornadus-T).
Still, the council wanted to get the job done, and done well, that's why they resuspected Keldeo, to close the Gen and move on to the next one on solid bases.
They did what anybody with half a brain would do, by isolating the things they wanted to examine.
Now, what I am wondering is :
How in the blue hell, did Sableye-M get away so freaking easily when all it ever went through was a suspect test shared by the most cancerous Pokémon I've ever seen in ORAS (Gothitelle) ?
We're talking about a Pokémon that is not only most likely broken thanks to its combination of Magic Bounce, typing, and solid bulk, but also at the epicenter of most of the cheaper strategies out there. But nah, for god knows which reason, it seems like it got thrown under the carpet right before a new generation comes out. Do you realise how tedious this will be to ever make a call in the future, once this generation won't be the main anymore ? Do you realise how much we're already screwed given that the next Official Tournaments won't even be using ORAS anymore ? The next to come being OST and SPL, which will be most surely featuring the new games.
You guys did poorly there, period. Why would you even hold back, personally I'm not even sure Sableye-M would be banned, but at least I'd like to see a suspect in order to freaking move on and let the policy follow its natural flow. I want the job to get done well, and you're really not helping so far I'd say.
I won't even talk about Dugtrio because honestly I doubt anybody will give a crap about this thing if we finally manage to balance Stall as a playstyle, and make it more fair (which the removal of Gothitelle helped already a ton, no doubt).
Just like no one gives a crap about it now that Sun is gone in BW, it's an interesting gimmick, that's all.
Anyway, how comes we're 2 games into a generation, and Baton Pass is still being so damn lame after going through what ? 2 or 3 suspects ?
How comes everybody half knowledgeable about this generation would agree that the sheer abundance of very solid threats is pressuring way too much the limited amount of team slots one could have, but we've almost not been suspecting anything to balance the metagame so far ? Instead, we're stuck on getting rid of the uncompetitive elements like Baton Pass or Shadow Tag CS trick garbage like we're 2 weeks into a new generation.
I mean, I wish we could have suspected.. I don't know Manaphy (you know, that thing that you can't virtually cover, that'd have been a start) for instance. I don't even know if I would want to have it banned, but hell I want for sure to see how it goes, I want to discuss the possiblity, I want the community to work towards a better metagame for the tournaments I play.
This generation just felt like a wasted potential, and there was no reason for it to happen because XY wasn't even bad at the end (just Greninja was dumb as crap, unless you want to accept having Clefable in every single team basically).
So I don't know if you guys are half dead half inactive, or if you're thinking "yup, perfecto, this is the dream generation", but either way, I'm starting to become disillusioned instead of cynical. It feels like you're trying to make the choices in everybody's place. Don't get it twisted, it's your role to choose the topic of the discussion, but you shouldn't be deciding the outcome on your own. You don't decide if Sableye-M gets banned or not, you decide if it gets suspected or not, and that's not nearly the same.
Now I don't know if you want to see the next thread being about a Chansey suspect, but I sure don't, so get this damn magic bouncing piece of crap suspected as soon as possible, in order to let everybody move on to a new generation that'll be hopefully better, and let us put behind what hopefully will become a half decent metagame after that suspect.
Cheers.
Yes, ideally testing two Pokemon at once is not optimal as the focus of our voters put their attention onto one of the Pokemon and have the other be ignored. While generally this is true, a lot of the time we test multiple Pokemon at once for the sake of saving time or for their extreme similarities. In this case, Sableye and Shadow Tag were components that made some Stall teams seem too strong or too good. Testing them together was seen as a non-issue and fact of the matter is the Council and the community saw them both as equal issues. Even if we wanted to test one at a time, how would we decide which should be the priority? These Pokemon were so closely intertwined alongside the fact both were seen as equal issues; what exactly should we have done? Arbitrarily tested one first when the other could have been the root of the issue or deem the other one not to even be Suspect worthy is the only option we had aside from testing them both at once. Even if we decided on which should be tested first, this specific situation isn't remotely like testing Keldeo and Tornadus-T or even the first test in XY; these Pokemon were almost entirely seen on the same team, both restricted your ability to break certain teams, and both were equally important of our attention at the time.
I understand your point about wanting to progress the metagame as fast as possible and doing tests late may cause issues, but Sableye was never thought of as a immediate concern by some of us. Sure, some of us may be pro-ban now or were during the Suspect, but no one pushed for a test to happen because they didn't feel it was a pressing concern. Obviously no one needs to break their back over wanting a Suspect in the Council, but not once do I recall anyone asking about testing Sableye again and the only times non-Council members brought it up to me were the ever-so-random comments on PS such as "TDK ban Sableye already" and "TDK ban Sableye pls" which I generally ignored after the same people already asked a few times. The last time one of us brought up testing Mega Sableye in the Council channel was in April where everyone unanimously agreed to doing nothing with Mega Sableye in the immediate future.
I know what's expected from a Tier Leader and I know how to keep track of my metagame and its community. I can't speak for everyone in the Council; there have been periods of inactivity. Around the time I took leadership the channel somewhat died for a period of time until I brought up SM tiering, which we discussed a fair amount. With that said, we have most definitely not been inactive in the slightest in the past few months. To say that we're lazy, incompetent, or just don't care is not only insulting but an absurd comment to make when you simply aren't in the Council channel. I did not believe Mega Sableye needed one myself and still don't, but am perfectly alright with it getting tested as I can see why it's an issue and why people believe it should be tested.
Also general thing: just because it's late in the generation does not mean something is immune to be tested; if it is test worthy, it will be tested. I would much rather finish up this generation with the best metagame possible, albeit quite late, than to have something that needs to be fixed down the road by a PR thread similar to Baton Pass in Old Gens and Sand Veil. If someone, whether an offhand comment from someone, from a Council member, or from myself, told you Sableye was not going to get tested they either; 1) assumed something they don't know, 2) were wrong, 3) weren't clear or said something to be left alone. If there is something you should be brought up, I don't care what people say; feel free to bring it up again. I don't mind taking PMs about potential Suspects if someone is unsure on if they should bother posting about it elsewhere. I would much rather have something the people think is potentially too strong be brought to my attention than for it to be ignored. This is not to say I need people doing my job for me; I am perfectly capable of keeping up with the metagame and knowing what I think of every Pokemon, but knowing the public opinion on certain Pokemon is always nice to know.
PDC already covered everything else I care to say.